Book Censorship News, July 28, 2023

“Yes Means Yes,” and Other Ways Consent Is Sexy: A Quick Guide

Book review of My Black Country by Alice Randall

Should AI Companies Buy Publishers for Access to Their Data?

Kelly is a former librarian and a long-time blogger at STACKED. She’s the editor/writer of (DON’T) CALL ME CRAZY: 33 VOICES START THE CONVERSATION ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH and the editor/writer of HERE WE ARE: FEMINISM FOR THE REAL WORLD. Her subsequent e book, BODY TALK, will publish in Fall 2020. Follow her on Instagram @heykellyjensen.

View All posts by Kelly Jensen

As a response to challenges from the general public and/or the state, a number of public libraries throughout the nation have come to compromises with these our bodies by way of entry to assortment supplies for minors. Among the compromises are library playing cards with age restrictions. In some amenities, all library playing cards for these below 18 have been made void and each little one now must reapply for a brand new card with parental/guardian restriction selections on them. In different amenities, the brand new playing cards primarily based on age are being carried out both when outdated playing cards expire or when a brand new card is requested. Age-restriction playing cards would possibly seem like limiting entry to supplies for these below 8 in a single class, these within the 8-12 class, and/or these within the 12-18 class. Every library going this route is doing so a bit in another way.

These playing cards not solely go in opposition to every little thing a public library stands for, however they’re a software of censorship. And whereas it’s a technique of avoiding issues from the neighborhood or the state — so learn this figuring out most public libraries going this route should not doing so with no lot of thought — these age-restricted playing cards are opening up the potential for infinite lawsuits at public libraries.

Although it’s dad and mom/guardians who will decide what card is acceptable for his or her little one, that’s the place the parental accountability ends. Now, each choice afterward falls explicitly on the general public library. Knowing how litigious right-wingers pushing for such measures are, they, too, are absolutely conscious that their “parental rights” arguments actually imply they wish to foist the actual parental tasks off on underpaid, overworked, deeply battered public service staff like librarians (and educators, after all). Demanding a library create separate playing cards for various age teams and prohibit sure supplies primarily based on these playing cards isn’t about parenting. It’s about making certain you don’t truly should mother or father. You get to log out on a card and let the library deal with it from there.

So for the libraries doing this, some questions.

What occurs when a circulation employee miscategorizes one of many playing cards when an adolescent and their authorized guardian indicators up for one? This just isn’t out of the realm of chance within the least, notably with how cumbersome such adjustments or modifications will be with an built-in library system (and particularly if that system is shared amongst totally different libraries who’re providing totally different “levels” of entry). One mistaken click on and all of the sudden, right-wing mommy’s daughter, who’s 16, has checked out Gender Queer, which is a no-no for card holders within the below 18 class. Who will get sued then? Is it the person who made a mistake? Not probably; they gained’t have cash. It’ll be the library itself, placing the whole facility and its funding in a chokehold — once more, that is exactly what that contingent of oldsters wish to have occur.

No one is naive sufficient to consider that these playing cards will prohibit what younger folks have a look at if they’re within the facility. What occurs when right-wing Johnny’s son decides to go to the library after faculty along with his under-18 card and reads Let’s Talk About It: The Teen’s Guide to Sex, Relationships, and Being a Human (A Graphic Novel) within the stacks however by no means truly borrows it? Two issues instantly come to thoughts: the mother or father will declare that the library did not uphold their guarantees with the age-restricted card and/or they are going to demand that library staff test playing cards on the door and monitor the place their youngsters are always. This turns library staff into babysitters, police, and censors all on the identical time.

None of these issues are their job nor their accountability. (Besides, police shouldn’t be within the library anyway, however that’s been properly coated already). But it is going to turn out to be their accountability the second a minor does the factor an adolescent does as a result of they’re an adolescent: break the “rules.”

We’re again to the chance for lawsuits, paired with histrionics about how libraries are giving youngsters porn. Their paper terrorism will develop to terrorism through the courts.

A ultimate consideration: what occurs when the library’s card restricts entry to supplies which might be important for the younger one that is at school? At Keene Public Library in Nebraska, for instance, the brand new card classes will solely permit younger folks to borrow objects that fall inside their class. For these between 13 and 18, they are going to solely be capable of borrow objects within the younger grownup part or decrease. What occurs if they should get a replica of The Great Gatsby for college? Or a Shakespeare play? What about any traditional work of literature that isn’t reshelved within the YA part (and thus a legal responsibility now as a result of they aren’t younger grownup books?).

Worse, these identical youngsters may have no entry to the print supplies they could want for an evidence-based analysis paper exterior of the fabric within the younger grownup part. While YA nonfiction has numerous nice stuff, it’s not going to be sufficient to supply the strong analysis wanted to finish an task.

So now, the identical right-wing christofascists who cite false data as reality get precisely what they need: a younger era of people that couldn’t even entry information or analysis that’s peer reviewed and edited and revealed by respected retailers. Those youngsters should rely on the web for his or her sources or hope to have sufficient classroom classes to know the right way to navigate library databases and the right way to differentiate reality from right-wing reality on the subject of the web. This is all predicated on the idea that minors will even have entry to their library’s digital sources. They don’t in states like Mississippi. We’ll additionally ignore how a lot reality is locked behind a paywall and the way abundantly free the pretend stuff is, all of which has helped to even convey us to the place we’re on this second of censorship-excited historical past.

These sorts of restrictions will simply flip younger folks off to the library all collectively. We’ve already seen how e book bans have brought on college students to cease going to their faculty library and stopped studying, interval. A populous who has misplaced curiosity in studying and studying, one who has misplaced these inherent traits because of the actions of their radicalized dad and mom, guardians, aunts, uncles, cousins, and neighbors, is a populous rife for being sucked into those self same harmful mindsets.

That’s exactly what the christofascists need.

We additionally know that restricted playing cards aren’t the reply that the e book disaster actors need. What they need are restricted playing cards AND restricted books, making certain that the library is unable to maintain up with the ever-shifting aim posts and so they get to maintain speaking about how their wants should not being met and due to this fact, why assist the library in any respect?

The reply isn’t within the playing cards.

Book Censorship News: July 28, 2023

Several Texas booksellers have filed a lawsuit in opposition to the state for his or her new e book rankings regulation. This is nice information on many fronts, together with the actual fact it ought to hinder the regulation’s date of enactment, which is slated for September 1.
One of the issues I coated earlier this 12 months was {that a} frontier to anticipate being explored is libraries withdrawing from bigger sharing methods/cooperatives. Yancey County Public Library (NC) had a proposal on the board agenda for simply this this week. Why? Pride month shows in a special library within the consortium. It didn’t go.
Fort Worth Independent School District (TX) eliminated three books from district cabinets. Gender Queer and Flamer seem like two of the titles. Bonus factors for the lady who complained at a board assembly conveniently not having youngsters within the district anymore.
Montgomery County Libraries (TX), which beforehand selected to limit LGBTQ+ books from teen readers, is now going to extend the conservative books of their assortment. This is antithetical to every little thing a public library stands for, and the legislators pulling the strings right here know that.
Metropolitan School District of Steuben County (IN) eliminated a number of books from center and highschool cabinets. We don’t know the total checklist, and the books should not going away utterly. Instead — that is no joke — “Any titles that were on the list have been pulled to a section that requires the media specialist to hand that book to the child and they have a conversation and check appropriateness for the child and the age of the material.” Isn’t this the coparenting with the federal government that the disaster actors don’t need? And why would you place the onus of such a dialog on the librarian? We aren’t going to say the privateness issue college students now now not have.
I Am Billy Jean King will stay on cabinets in Leon County, Florida faculties.
Temecula School District (CA) is adapting the California social research curriculum they’ve been preventing in opposition to however nonetheless plan to not discuss Harvey Milk.
Earlier this month within the roundup of disruptions and dismantling of Pride occasions and shows, I included a narrative of two ladies who checked out all the Pride books on show at one of many San Diego Public Libraries (CA). Guess what? Their censorship backfired [gifted NYT link].
This is a narrative operating on a Fox affiliate station from The National Desk, one of many right-wing retailers who’s a serious participant in proudly owning the information cycle over e book ban disaster performing. The motive for linking is the continued perception that Libs of TikTook is a professional supply for something and since it targets entry to This Book Is Gay in a Kimberly, Wisconsin center faculty digital library.
Here’s the most recent from the Moms for Liberty’s makes an attempt to inform the Charlotte Mecklenburg Schools (NC) the right way to do their job. This is the board that met with them firstly of final faculty 12 months one-on-one.
Wake County Schools, additionally in North Carolina, have a brand new e book problem coverage.
New Hanover County (NC) is holding one other assembly to find out whether or not or to not ban Stamped from the faculties.
Campbell County Public Library System — a protracted embattled one in Wyoming — is now questioning whether or not their skilled librarians are able to doing their literal job of weeding.
An replace on the Erie County Public Library’s (PA) removing of a Pride show final month within the youngsters’s space. It seems like numerous mess.
A choose says that Stamped will stay off cabinets whereas it’s below overview in Pickens County Schools (SC). That…just isn’t nice.
Eastern Howard School Corporation and the Greentown Public Library (IN) are struggling to determine the right way to serve patrons with the state’s new legal guidelines in opposition to “inappropriate materials” in faculties.
Grangeville Centennial Library (ID) is not going to be reclassifying practically a dozen YA books from the YA part to grownup.
I’m paywalled, however right here’s how the St. Charles County libraries (MO) are creating new library card classifications.
“Several students at North Smithfield High School [RI] are speaking out after noting that an elective class that drew criticism from parents this year will not be offered next fall. A class dubbed, ‘Gothic Literature and Fairy Tales,’ is not on the roster for the 2023/2024 school year, according to students speaking before the School Committee on Tuesday, July 18. The class came under scrutiny in March after parents questioned inclusion in the curriculum of The Virgin Suicides, a 1993 novel that centers on five sisters who all take their own lives in a single year.” They canceled a complete ELECTIVE class over the usage of a e book that’s acceptable to be used with this age group and on this class.
This article will publish earlier than the decision is understood, however the choice over a lawsuit in Arkansas over new “inappropriate books” laws impacting libraries will come this week.
Academy District 20 (Colorado) put a number of books again on faculty cabinets. The books are Push, Identical, and Lucky, all of which had been returned when the Bible was challenged below the identical tips used to drag the opposite titles.
“Octogenarian Betty Van Bibber, wearing a straw hat with a paper band reading ‘Stop Pornography in Children’s Library’ quoted Bible verses and said, ‘When someone asks me what pornography is, I have the answer. Pornography is sin.’ Resident Zach Agnew said the controversy over some of the library’s books has brought the debated library materials into the spotlight.” Anyway, Saline County Public Library in Arkansas could also be below the rule of the choose quickly, board of administrators be damned.
Mankato Area Public Schools (MN) have now heard their first curriculum complaints in a very long time, and it’s over the usage of March by John Lewis utilized in an English class lesson about racism. Uh. Hmm.
This is an excellent piece concerning the patrons who confirmed as much as assist Athens County Public Libraries (OH) who stored their Pride shows and programming as-planned, somewhat than again all the way down to complainers.
Dayton Public Library in Washington, which is near shutting down and has been trying to maintain its doorways open, is appeasing the e book banners by relocating YA books to different locations within the library. Censoring to strive to not be shut down on account of lies unfold by e book banners. America 2023.
Boundary County Library (ID) is now making a nonsense “new adult” class of books for the library. This is what Samuels Library (VA) introduced they had been doing final week. 1. there isn’t any such factor (it’s a failed advertising idea so how are you going to find out what belongs there?) and a pair of. that’s going to confuse the hell out of patrons in search of new grownup books (as in, books for adults which might be new).
And Tango Makes Three is as soon as once more out there in Lake County, Florida elementary faculties.
A have a look at e book bans in Massachusetts during the last faculty 12 months and boy oh boy, have a look at the titles. Not a single shock amongst them as a result of e book banners should not inventive. They’re simply racist and bigoted.
In Polk County excessive faculties (FL), there may be at the moment a problem being processed over Assassination Classroom.
“King added he thought the Miller Test was intended to determine obscenity for adults and not for minors.” These individuals are in command of making instructional selections and so they don’t even know what the regulation means (or they purposefully misread it). Anyway, The Perks of Being a Wallflower will stay, with some restrictions as beforehand determined, in Sumner County Schools (TN).
Texas City, Texas seems like they’ve written a strong e book problem coverage. You can view it in full right here — given their neighbors in League City can’t as a lot as type a overview committee for a problem, that is refreshing.
Over on my private substack, I wrote about how the Montana State Library Commission withdrawing from the ALA shouldn’t be a shock as a result of there was nice protection main as much as this choice — one thing that may’t be mentioned in lots of locations.