Coming off the heels of The Witcher’s last season with Henry Cavill, an government producer of the fantasy collection got here ahead to deal with some followers’ accusations that the present’s writers don’t respect the books.
On July 28, a day after the second half of The Witcher Season Three launched on Netflix, government producer Javier Grillo-Marxuach tweeted a reference to a scene within the sixth episode of the third season as a one-to-one recreation of what happens in creator Andrzej Sapkowski’s books as proof that the present’s writers pay shut consideration to how occasions transpire within the authentic story.
“For those who claim that we don’t read/respect the books, the writers’ draft of The Witcher 306 ABSOLUTELY began with Dykstra holding Geralt at knifepoint as he pissed into a plant,” Grillo-Marxuach wrote. “I have the pages to prove it.”
However, some have been fast to level out that Grillo-Marxuach’s efforts to show that present writers pay shut consideration to the books have been undermined by each his misspelling of Dijkstra’s name and followers’ declare that the aforementioned scene doesn’t play out how he says it does in the books.
Although the occasions do transpire comparatively near what Grillo-Marxuach states happen in Sapkowski’s books, IGN notes that the scene isn’t a precise illustration of what occurred within the novels. According to IGN, Dijkstra guards are those who restrain Geralt within the English translation of the books. Though to be honest to Grillo-Marxuach, even probably the most die-hard Witcher followers scrutinize the English translation of the books. All that being mentioned, it’s a bit distressing that The Witcher collection discourse has ramped as much as the purpose that writers really feel compelled to make use of this particular scene to beat fan allegations that present writers actively dislike Sapkowski’s books.
Read More: Witcher Producer Blames Young American Audience For Viewership Decline
The Witcher discourse is at an all-time excessive with Cavill’s exit
Since The Witcher debuted on the streamer in 2017, the present has confronted an uphill battle with followers for its peculiar pacing and introduction of small deviations of occasions that transpire in Polish author Sapkowski’s novels. The latter level of competition furthered rumors amongst followers that Geralt actor Cavill, who’s a fan of the books, introduced his departure from the present on the finish of its third season to get replaced by Hunger Games actor Liam Hemsworth, due to his frustration with Witcher showrunners deviation from the books. Although the true motive for Cavill’s departure is unknown, his last season on the present noticed a drop in viewership, which led a producer to position the blame squarely on the brief consideration span of youthful viewers.
In a reply to a remark saying the present’s discourse comes from rumors and “flat-out lies” from unhealthy religion viewers leaping on a hate marketing campaign with out studying the novels, Grillo-Marxuach mentioned, “Those of us who know what really went down behind the scenes know what really went down behind the scenes. I stand behind the work, and my boss, 100 percent.”
Read More: The Witcher Season 3 Ended As It Began—Messily
In a separate reply to a fan inquiring about how the present will clarify Geralt’s new look in Season Four of The Witcher, Grillo-Marxuach replied saying, “It will be done in a way that is very much in line with the thematic spirit of the books.”
In Kotaku’s commentary for The Witcher Season Three, Alyssa Mercante mentioned: “The series can be so convoluted that I wonder if my knowledge of the lore is harming more than helping, as I struggle to recall events that happened seasons ago and wonder if I’m actually remembering something from the books.” All issues thought of, Mercante nonetheless plans on watching the upcoming Ciri-led season.
Discussion about this post