I simply completed a YA novel that I actually loved, and I went over to Goodreads to depart a ranking. One of the highest evaluations stated it was unreadable as a result of of the quantity of popular culture references in it, one thing I hadn’t observed in any respect. Who do authors hold doing this, the overview stated; don’t they know readers hate it?
Of course, simply because some readers hate a trope or writing type doesn’t imply most or all do. In reality, probably the most complained about authors are normally additionally those that promote probably the most. It’s simple to see a handful of folks on-line speak about one thing and get the impression it’s a universally agreed upon reality.
Personally, the hate for popular culture references in books has at all times baffled me. It’s normally described as “cringey”. But why? What’s so embarrassing about references to our present media panorama?
In a YA novel written by an grownup, perhaps it comes throughout as attempting too laborious, however I don’t see this type of power for slang in YA novels, which is — for my part — a way more direct model of this.
The motive I’ve seen used most frequently as a degree in opposition to popular culture references in books is that it dates them. So let’s check out this in three components: do popular culture references date books? Is it the factor that dates books probably the most? And is grounding your guide in a selected time a nasty factor within the first place?
First, do popular culture references date books? In probably the most literal means, undoubtedly. If we all know the Beatles are performing, then we all know this isn’t a present YA title. But there’s a wide range within the sorts of popular culture that get referenced and the place they place the guide in time. Referencing a meme that was solely in style for a month will really feel dated between the time it was written and the time it was revealed. Referencing Taylor Swift, although, could possibly be wherever in a 15-year timeframe, and there’s no signal she’ll be stopping any time quickly.
I feel what irks me concerning the popular culture reference complaints probably the most is the concept that in any other case, a guide would exist fully exterior of time. If you’re writing a up to date story, although, it’s essentially going to be dated. Do the characters have cell telephones, as an example? How do they use them? Whichever selection you make, you’re tying your guide to a time interval. The language utilized in dialogue dates a guide, and so do their hobbies, their jobs, their values, and extra. Some of these decisions would possibly go away a wider vary of time it might apply to, however no story set in our world exists exterior of time fully.
And most significantly, what’s so unhealthy about having your guide set in a sure time? Just as historic fiction is grounded in its setting, so are up to date books. For YA novels particularly, these characters are immersed in a selected media panorama, political surroundings, and day-to-day actuality that impacts who they’re. You can select to set the guide in a world with out COVID, as an example, however that’s an alternate universe, not ours.
In reality, attempting laborious to make a YA novel not be dated could be a lot cringier than mentioning TikTok. If none of your teenage characters use any present slang, they’re not likely talking like youngsters. And they’ll appear a lot much less well-rounded if they’ll’t make references to any media. Even worse could be characters that inexplicably are all obsessive about music and media from a long time in the past — say, the time interval when the writer was an adolescent? It can come throughout as stilted and out of contact.
So why do authors write popular culture references in books? For one, as a result of it is sensible to the character. A nerdy teenager goes to make fandom references; that’s virtually a regulation. A music lover goes to say present artists. And the category clown might be going to make jokes about what’s within the information or on their social media feeds.
Besides, I don’t simply not hate popular culture references as a reader: I typically like them. Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir is a guide brimming with popular culture references, and followers love discovering them. If I learn a guide that references none pizza, left beef, it can have my coronary heart ceaselessly, even when it’s now very dated. Stale, even. Pop tradition references could make a guide really feel extra life like and relatable; it may be enjoyable to share pursuits with the principle character. And recognizing popular culture references is satisfying. There’s a motive they get written into books within the first place.
So please, I’m begging readers: do not forget that your private pet peeves in books aren’t common guidelines. Just put down that guide and stroll away — don’t argue that it shouldn’t have been written in any respect. There are a lot of books that reduce popular culture references so that you can learn. You don’t must erase them from all tales. In the imply time, move those you rejected my means.
Discussion about this post