THIS WEEK: The DC Round-Up crew convenes for his or her first roundtable dialogue of the brand new yr, overlaying 4 massive new DC releases together with Lazarus Planet: Assault on Krypton, Nightwing #100, The New Champion of Shazam! #4, and Batman – One Bad Day: Bane.
Note: the critiques beneath include spoilers. If you need a fast, spoiler-free purchase/move advice on the comics in query, try the underside of every dialogue for our remaining verdicts.
Lazarus Planet: Assault on Krypton #1
Writers: Nicole Maines, C.S. Pacat, Frank Barbiere, and Leah Williams
Artists: Skylar Patridge, Scott Godlewski, Sami Basri with Vicente Cifuentes, and Marguerite Sauvage
Colorists: Nick Filardi, Alex Guimarães, HiFi, and Marguerite Sauvage
Letterers: Andworld’s Morgan Martinez, Andworld Design, Dave Sharpe, and Becca Carey
Cover Artists: David Marquez & Alejandro Sánchez
Zack Quaintance: Hey crew! It’s been some time since we’ve roundtabled (all the best way again in October!), however right here we’re simply three Tuesdays into a brand new yr and there are DC Comics that demand to be talked about. Lucky for the nice readers of The Beat, we now have reconvened to just do that. First and foremost, I wish to know…what did you all consider Lazarus Planet: Assault on Krypton #1?
Cori McCreery: For me Assault on Krypton was a slam dunk. Particularly the 2 bookend items that includes Dreamer and Power Girl. Both went out of their approach to be psychedelic and trippy, and it made the entire comedian a blast.
Quaintance: When I learn that comedian, I believed, ‘oh this is all very much Cori’s favourite issues.’
Joe Grunenwald: I additionally actually loved Assault on Krypton. These anthology one-shots are inclined to normally be a combined bag in my e-book, however this one had 4 actually strong tales from begin to end. I feel the Power Girl story from Leah Williams and Marguerite Sauvage was in all probability the strongest story for me.
Quaintance: I favored it lots too. Each of those tales performed to what I take into account the strengths of this occasion: the character of what’s occurring within the broader narrative (a worldwide Lazarus rain!) offers creators freedom and permits them to be additive, plus additionally Batman is sidelined.
McCreery: It’s arduous for me to select a favourite of the 2 bookend tales if I’m being sincere. On the one hand one was Dreamer by Nicole Maines. On the opposite, Leah Williams is considered one of my favourite writers in comics. I’m gonna name it a draw.
Quaintance: I really feel like each these tales will proceed to play out elsewhere throughout this occasion, so maybe a winner will emerge down the road.
McCreery: The Power Girl story is constant in subsequent week’s Action Comics #1051 truly!
Grunenwald: The Dreamer story was additionally very, very robust. This is, what, the third comedian from Maines? It’s spectacular. If I had a grievance about this e-book it’s that it’s all just about setup for what’s to come back. Most of the tales had endings, but it surely’s all nonetheless simply placing items in place for different tales.
McCreery: Yeah, it was Maines’s third comedian, and first solo outing in mainline continuity. Which is a hell of a factor to be thrown an occasion comedian so early in your profession.
Grunenwald: It definitely doesn’t damage that Skylar Patridge is a hell of an artist to be teamed with.
McCreery: One of the best possible within the enterprise, in my humble opinion.
Quaintance: I do get your level in regards to the setup, Joe. It’s type of a operate of how this occasion is structured with the Alpha and Omega bookends (which is shortly changing into the phrase of the roundtable), and all of the one-shots in between, a construction that I like. I’ll say although, that I feel this a lot setup is okay if it’s paid off nicely down the road.
McCreery: Say what did you two take into consideration the shock visitor within the Power Girl story? Were you as gobsmacked by her inclusion as I used to be?
Quaintance: I feel we will title the visitor, what with our spoiler disclaimer I assume Joe will add to this at the beginning…
Grunenwald: Yeah, we undoubtedly can.
Quaintance: We’re speaking about Julie Andrews, proper?
McCreery: Clearly.
Grunenwald: How dare you. You will respect Lilith Clay. I used to be actually surprised to see her. I don’t keep in mind the final time I noticed her in one thing, particularly one thing that wasn’t particularly Titans-related.
Quaintance: You two are a lot larger Titans-heads (is {that a} factor) than I’m, so I’ll defer to you to gauge normal gobsmackery right here.
McCreery: I in all probability would have listed not less than three dozen DC characters I’d count on to see in a Power Girl story earlier than Omen, for certain.
Grunenwald: Where was her boyfriend, Gnaark? (I do know, he died at Sanctuary.) Usually obscure Titans characters are solely trotted out when it’s time to kill off characters en masse, although, so it was good to see Omen in a non-dead capability.
Quaintance: Okay, we’re on the Gnaark level within the chat, so I feel we will safely transfer to our verdicts for this one…the place did you all land right here?
McCreery: I feel I made it fairly clear that this e-book is a BUY from me,
Grunenwald: Yeah, that is an simple BUY for me as nicely. A quartet of strong tales that arrange attention-grabbing bits for future comics.
Quaintance: I’m additionally a BUY, with an additional emphasis for individuals who are present with all issues Lazarus Planet, which needs to be most people studying this as a result of it’s been actual good.
Nightwing #100
Writer: Tom Taylor
Artists: Bruno Redondo, Scott McDaniel, Rick Leonardi, Eddy Barrows, Javier Fernandez, and Mikel Janín
Inkers: Karl Story, Eber Ferreira, Caio Felipe, and Joe Prado with Rick Leonardi
Colorist: Adriano Lucas
Letterer: Wes Abbot
Cover Artist: Bruno Redondo
Quaintance: Speaking of Titans! Next up we now have Nightwing #100! A milestone challenge from the title’s present artistic crew Tom Taylor, Bruno Redondo, Adriano Lucas, and Wes Abbot, with a cadre of visitor artists and inkers, too, as a result of it clocks in at practically 60 pages. What did you all consider this one?
Grunenwald: I feel we’ve all been fairly overwhelmingly constructive about this e-book since Taylor, Redondo, & co. took over because the common crew, so it’ll in all probability come as no shock that I liked this challenge. The crew does an amazing job tying up a variety of plot threads they’ve been constructing since they took over, whereas additionally seeding some large issues for the sequence and the bigger DCU.
McCreery: There had been elements I actually favored, and elements that fell a little bit extra flat for me on this one. It’s bizarre as a result of the cavalcade of artists was one which did each of these. It was implausible to see them honor Nightwing’s solo historical past with artists who’ve labored on the e-book earlier than, but it surely additionally made elements really feel extraordinarily disjointed to me.
Grunenwald: I undoubtedly get what you’re saying in regards to the artwork shifts, Cori. The types on show from artists like Scott McDaniel and Rick Leonardi had been all so wildly completely different that it did really feel a little bit disjointed. I feel having Redondo and Lucas act as buffers between the type shifts was a useful approach to unify every little thing, although.
McCreery: Yeah, I feel the place the place it actually caught out like a sore thumb for me was the sequence of pinup pages that had been simply meant to showcase his numerous costumes. And nonetheless managed to overlook one.
Quaintance: Agreed in regards to the pinups, however yeah from a important perspective, I feel anybody who has been having fun with this sequence month-to-month will certainly get pleasure from this one, which is the purpose, it’s a payoff factor, not a brand new leaping on level, however I don’t actually have a lot qualitative to say about it…I’m much more desirous about listening to what you all thought of the established order stuff that occurs on the finish…
Grunenwald: I feel placing the grownup Titans on this e-book full-time is an excellent transfer. They’ve mainly been recurring visitor stars as it’s. I’m additionally glad to see the occasions of Dark Crisis paying off in a considerable method on this sequence.
McCreery: I discover the established order change on the finish very attention-grabbing, as a result of it actually appeared like this challenge was setting Dick as much as be the chief of a brand new Justice League, however as an alternative it pays off with what appears to be the elevation of the Titans into the heavy hitter slot of the DC Universe. Not simply including the Titans to the JLA like has occurred prior to now, however making the precise Titans title the massive one for DC is an attention-grabbing method for this new period.
Quaintance: I ponder if the transfer isn’t to ultimately do each. On one hand, it looks as if they’re type of Trojan Horse-ing a brand new extra conventional Titans lineup right into a month-to-month sequence right here through the month-to-month Nightwing comedian. Which I feel is sweet? I undoubtedly prefer it higher than something the Titans have been as much as as of late in their very own titles, none of which have had a lot endurance.
I don’t know. I feel there’s some questions left…like is Nightwing going to remain with them, or is he passing Bludhaven to them? Will Nightwing then go to coordinate world league exercise? And additionally has Wally been demoted as a result of the Flash’s important energy is to simply run away?
Grunenwald: Hilarious, Quaintance. At least he’s not on a moped.
McCreery: Beep beep scoot scoot
Grunenwald: I get the sensation that Dick’s not desirous about leaving Blüdhaven in any respect, and that’s why they’re organising store there. That’s how I learn it, anyway.
McCreery: Yeah that was my thought too. Setting the Titans up in Blüdhaven is a method for him to be a significant a part of a crew whereas nonetheless being near dwelling.
Quaintance: However it seems, I for one am all for placing Nightwing on the middle of no matter occurs transferring forward for the DCU. Correct me if I’m improper, however I feel the Future State: Justice League title is without doubt one of the solely ones left that’s but to type of payoff within the common DC continuity? Maybe that is clearing the trail as much as begin heading towards that Justice League iteration post-Dark Crisis…
Grunenwald: That’s a very good level. And with the Teen Justice mini having wrapped, Jess Chambers is on the market once more to cross over to Earth-0.
McCreery: Be awhile earlier than Andy is sufficiently old to hitch the crew although, until she will get Jon Kented.
Quaintance: Oh proper. There’s undoubtedly some lingering questions left round how these dots get related. Whatever the case, I feel the final dozen pages or so actually made this a must-read comedian for folk who’re desirous about following the broader DCU. So, I’m a BUY on this one.
McCreery: I feel I’ll say BROWSE for this one, BUY if you happen to’ve been following the sequence, in any other case let your coronary heart information you.
Grunenwald: Another simple BUY for me as nicely. Along with organising massive issues for the longer term, I feel it’s an amazing highlight for what units Nightwing other than the remainder of the Bat-family and most different heroes within the DCU.
The New Champion of Shazam! #4
Writer: Josie Campbell
Artist: Evan “Doc” Shaner
Letterer: Becca Carey
Cover Artist: Evan “Doc” Shaner
Quaintance: Next up, we now have New Champion of SHAZAM #4, which brings a miniseries that we’ve all been fairly excessive on to an in depth. What did you all suppose, did Josie Campbell, Doc Shaner, and Becca Carey stick the touchdown?
McCreery: Yeah I feel they did. This sequence was pleasant for all 4 points, and actually did an amazing job of creating Mary as <sigh> Shazam! in her personal proper.
Quaintance: Delightful is an ideal phrase for this e-book.
Grunenwald: That sigh is a giant temper, Cori, however unhealthy title apart I agree this e-book did an amazing job elevating Mary to headliner standing in a very enjoyable method.
Quaintance: Hey, they even made gentle of the title factor on this challenge, which was a enjoyable second.
McCreery: They did but it surely didn’t make me really feel any higher about it. I’m by no means gonna be down with the title change of the Marvel Family.
Grunenwald: I did recognize the acknowledgement, even when it’s nonetheless a little bit groan-worthy. She can’t inform individuals her personal title with out altering again into Mary! How is {that a} workable answer! But I’m getting hung up on one factor of an in any other case general nice sequence.
Quaintance: The title factor is actual unlucky, however yeah, that apart, I feel that is primarily an ideal refresh for SHAZAM! comics at DC. It type of captures the spirit of what makes these characters participating and enjoyable, whereas kicking the ball down the sphere narratively, so to talk.
McCreery: Yeah the ‘not being able to tell people your name’ factor was Freddie’s schtick! Now that poor child has nothin.
Grunenwald: Poor CM3.
Quaintance: The final web page made me chuckle a little bit, the place it’s form of like, alls nicely that ends nicely, aye gang? Oh dang, wait, Billy is like strapped to the Rock of Eternity and in a state of fixed ache and battle! But it’s good to see this character off to do one thing necessary with a transparent subsequent place to seek out her adventures. And sure, the artwork on this sequence was because it will get.
McCreery: Shaner’s artwork is all the time a should purchase, and much more when he’s engaged on a personality he loves as a lot as he does Shazam!
Grunenwald: Shaner’s work is stellar as all the time, and in contrast to on different books he’s labored on it was good to see it uninterrupted for all 4 points. The Lazarus Planet tie-in on the finish was additionally a very nice contact and tease for what’s subsequent.
Quaintance: Great issues throughout. So sure, BUY from me right here, and if you happen to haven’t been studying this e-book, make a little bit notice to get the commerce, it’s one begin to end.
McCreery: Yeah undoubtedly a BUY for me too.
Grunenwald: BUY right here, too, or seize the gathering when it comes out. It’ll look good in your bookshelf.
Batman – One Bad Day: Bane #1
Writer: Joshua Williamson
Artist: Howard Porter
Colorist: Tomeu Morey
Letterer: Steve Wands
Cover Artists: Howard Porter with Tomeu Morey
Quaintance: Last up, we now have Batman – One Bad Day: Bane by Joshua Williamson, Howard Porter, Tomeu Morey, and Steve Wands. I’ll simply lead this by saying I had a blast with this one. What did you all suppose?
Grunenwald: I feel Joshua Williamson is making a pleasant area of interest for himself telling ‘final’ tales for traditional supervillains.
Quaintance: Between this and Rogues (which now that you just point out it was the topic of our final roundtable again in October), for certain.
McCreery: I feel I’m gonna be the contrarian on this one. I didn’t truly a lot take care of it. Part of that was Porter’s artwork, his fashionable stuff simply doesn’t do it for me prefer it did within the Nineties.
Quaintance: Well, I feel he now attracts with a distinct hand than he used to, however I loved the artwork on this e-book, which I believed match the character and particularly the wrestling-related sequences nicely.
Grunenwald: Porter’s work was undoubtedly the weak level of this challenge for me, however I believed together with the story that Williamson was telling it received the job executed fairly nicely. The wrestling sequences specifically, like Zack mentioned, had been actually strong.
McCreery: I did benefit from the wrestling sequences. The relaxation simply didn’t land with me for no matter cause.
Quaintance: I’m nothing if not a sucker for a narrative a few character who’s glory days are behind them, however I additionally simply suppose that is one of the best excessive idea but for considered one of these One Bad Day one-shots. It’s all primarily based round an amazing query: the place do you go after you’ve executed the unimaginable and damaged the bat?
Grunenwald: Every Bane story after Knightfall has actually paled compared to that story. It was good to see the in-universe acknowledgment of that.
McCreery: I disagree with that Joe. I feel Legacy holds up.
Grunenwald: In my thoughts Legacy is a Ra’s al Ghul story greater than it’s a Bane story.
Quaintance: I favored that it introduced again Knightfall characters and concepts in a method that type of made it learn like a Knightfall epilogue to some extent.
Grunenwald: Yes, Bane as an precise genius is one thing that feels prefer it will get misplaced or ignored in regards to the character.
Quaintance: Yeah, he typically simply will get boiled right down to massive drug man.
McCreery: Thanks, Batman & Robin.
Quaintance: Anyway, I’m a BUY on this one, which it needs to be famous you possibly can learn if you happen to haven’t learn any of the One Bad Day books, as a result of all of them stand on their very own.
McCreery: I’m gonna be the lone PASS this month with this e-book, and y’all are gonna make me really feel unhealthy for saying it.
Grunenwald: This one will get a BROWSE from me. As a giant fan of the unique Bane tales I really feel like it is a return to kind for the character, however the artwork left a little bit one thing to be desired.
Quaintance: And that may do it for this week’s DC Roundtable, which can hopefully be a little bit extra constant this yr! Thanks as all the time associates for becoming a member of.
Grunenwald: Closing with a hung jury! Doesn’t occur fairly often.
McCreery: BAH HUMBUG!
Miss any of our earlier critiques? Check out our full archive!
Discussion about this post