The Chuckling Whatsit
Writer/Artist: Richard Sala
Publisher: Fantagraphics
Originally Published: 1997
New Hardcover Edition: January 2023
The Chuckling Whatsit by Richard Sala — for the uninitiated — is a comics traditional. It is an idiosyncratic and deeply bizarre homicide thriller of a e-book, one which may be very a lot a superb cartoonist’s singular imaginative and prescient. In reality, when Sala handed away in 2020 not lengthy after the beginning of the pandemic, the e-book was among the many many causes The Beat praised him as one in all our favourite horror cartoonists, a staple of the location whose work we recurrently wrote about round Halloween. A grasp of noir and thrillers, Sala created a physique of labor stands as a real achievement.
The Chuckling Whatsit — first printed in 1997 — had been out of print for a while. This month, nevertheless, it not solely returned with a full printing, but it surely additionally acquired its first-ever hardcover edition, out now by way of writer Fantagraphics. While maybe not Sala’s most readily accessible work — that honor ought to in all probability go to the Snow White-skewing, Delphine — this new edition is a welcome reminder that the The Chuckling Whatsit is a timeless and towering achievement of each the spooky thriller style and of the graphic fiction medium.
With the new hardcover edition in hand, I revisited The Chuckling Whatsit to start out the 12 months. I used to be struck mainly with simply how singular the e-book feels, even for those that have learn Sala’s different work. It’s a scene-driven story during which a set of fascinating and superbly-designed weirdoes — all of whom are some kind of unsavory — bounce off of one another as dying lurks within the margins. The narrative feels free and chaotic till the barn-burning final sequence. There’s an nearly non-linear strategy to story right here, a complete disinterest in viewers hand-holding because it pertains to the characters and their numerous agendas, that are nearly to a one as shocking as they’re complicated. What guides the story as an alternative is a way that one thing sinister might be wherever at any time on this world amongst these outsiders. This all imbues The Chuckling Whatsit with an eerie and propulsive sense of rigidity, making for a speedy and jarring learn proper on by means of to the books ultimate pages.
The aspect that stood out most to me upon a second examination was Sala’s use of astrology. To me, astrology can really feel like a recreation of rooster with the coincidental (your mileage could fluctuate, after all). Inherently, one by no means is aware of if the observe is totally incidental, a recreation pushed by the shared experiences that folks have by being born in a given month, and that’s a part of what’s at work within the story. How a lot ought to the principal characters imagine about something? How a lot is simply coincidence? Should these concerned simply prostrate themselves on the alter of the unknown as they’re carried to their fates? Plus additionally, what’s with the key society and the masked murderer on the rooftops and the spooky-as-all-hell little dolls?
There’s rather a lot in The Chuckling Whatsit, all of which is attention-grabbing, to make sure. But the astrology motif is the one which kind of transcends the opposite touches, even because it’s used all through the e-book with restraint, which I feel is the correct transfer. The very last thing a plot that relies on ambiguity wants is all of its characters introducing themselves like, ‘Hi, I’m a Virgo, let’s speak about what which means.’ The different selection that basically works for the e-book and its curiosity in astrology is that the protagonist, Broom, is a reluctant — if not outright disinterested — astrologer. He’s the one we now have guiding us by means of this world and this thriller, and he doesn’t need to be any a part of it, probably not. He doesn’t like his job, he’s not particularly involved with the victims, and — as we discover out later — if not for the machinations of others within the shadows, he in all probability would have been killed instantly, a number of completely different occasions and in a number of other ways. That selection too is splendidly not belabored.
Illustrated with Sala’s black and white pen work, The Chuckling Whatsit in the long run is a narrative of a hapless investigator getting mired in a thriller that feels limitless, and, true to kind, the e-book doesn’t give us each final reply when it reaches its conclusion. It’s extra a journey of the atmospheric, a story tight-rope stroll the place you’re nearly rooting for the walker to fall simply to see what complete disaster may appear to be. I completely like it.
My different curiosity throughout this read-through was the bodily e-book itself, and I’m delighted to report that the new edition is beautiful. Jacob Covey and Daniel Clowes are credited with the e-book’s design, which is basically good, from the jarring colour distinction on the entrance cowl to the WHO WHAT WHERE WHY idea on the again, above a Sala femme fatale having a drink with a disembodied skeleton (simply good stuff). The e-book additionally includes a run by means of of the solid on the very finish, which can remind readers of simply how bonkers and diversified the folks in The Chuckling Whatsit actually are, kind of re-emphasizing how particular this e-book is because it closes. Finally, the e-book jacket has an extended and respectful rundown of Sala’s life and profession, which is a really good inclusion.
It all provides as much as a new hardcover that’s a worthy edition to any shelf; in case you’re wanting for a single Sala work so as to add to your assortment of graphic fiction, this is perhaps the one.
Discussion about this post