A Prison Banned Book Week News Roundup, 2023

Kelly is a former librarian and a long-time blogger at STACKED. She’s the editor/creator of (DON’T) CALL ME CRAZY: 33 VOICES START THE CONVERSATION ABOUT MENTAL HEALTH and the editor/creator of HERE WE ARE: FEMINISM FOR THE REAL WORLD. Her subsequent guide, BODY TALK, will publish in Fall 2020. Follow her on Instagram @heykellyjensen.

View All posts by Kelly Jensen

U.S. prisons stay the establishments the place probably the most censorship happens. This has not modified, at the same time as faculty and public library guide challenges have skyrocketed in numbers since 2021. Censorship thrives in prisons for a number of causes, together with the truth that the personal, for-profit business doesn’t have to care concerning the rights of these housed inside them. Indeed, it additionally thrives as a result of most of the people doesn’t perceive how dangerous the circumstances are for these experiencing incarceration, doesn’t perceive how the jail industrial complicated operates, and, frankly, most of the people doesn’t perceive why they need to care about those that are in jail.

This differs from colleges and public libraries, which have usually optimistic perceptions within the public eye. Moreover, those that use colleges and public libraries are those that are, by public notion, law-abiding residents (and in colleges, the notion is additional bolstered by the very fact these are youngsters).

Recidivism goes down when people experiencing incarceration have entry to books, however prisons restrict entry by not having libraries or solely having outdated and out-of-date supplies in these libraries; placing excessive limits on the place and the way books might be despatched to these inside the power; permitting mailroom staff to choose and select what they decide to be “appropriate”; or a mixture of those or different components. If entry to books decreases recidivism, then why would prisons restrict it a lot?

The reply is revenue.

Over the final two years, as censorship and guide bans have elevated in public establishments, the necessity to sort out jail censorship has not ended. If something, these working to alter this method and get books inside prisons are being heard even lower than they had been previous to the beginning of the pandemic. Access to digital books and the expertise to make use of them remained behind paywalls for too many who’re incarcerated, additional choking the rights of these in a time when the world outdoors–and, certainly, inside–was fully upended. Books continued to be banned or eliminated, and libraries continued to both not exist or fell into additional disarray, because of “budget” and “safety” issues.

Despite the very fact there continues to be a divide between the work being accomplished to make sure entry to books and libraries stays uninhibited for varsity and public library customers and people experiencing incarceration, the 2 actions will not be in opposition. If something, the optimistic steps ahead to make sure that books can’t be banned in class and public libraries (together with state-level legal guidelines like these in Illinois and people proposed in Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and others) are a chance to encourage these concerned on this struggle to not solely keep engaged however to construct data of and create motion round jail censorship.

Book ban payments might goal colleges and libraries particularly for now, however these actions are ahead actions and will create momentum to take the First Amendment Rights protections even additional. Indeed, it will make sense for guardian teams pushing in opposition to guide bans on the native degree at their colleges and libraries to attach with the leaders of anti-censorship campaigns in prisons and share their mutual data, their instruments, their wins, and their defeats. If entry to books means persons are much less more likely to return to jail as soon as they’re launched, is that not a lesson that must also be shared at college and library board conferences? If legislators have signed off on a invoice to finish guide bans in colleges and libraries, why not push for the subsequent measure of liberation and demand that each jail, public or personal, have a library outfitted with a full-time worker and books which have a mean publication date inside the final 5-10 years?

Wins in a single area are wins in all arenas…if motion continues.

We know that the identical issues driving individuals to ban books in colleges and libraries is similar actual bigotry and racism behind choking entry to books in prisons. It’s hatred, it’s energy, and it’s worry of what occurs when somebody is ready to see themselves or others in a narrative and grow to be empowered, enlightened, free. An educated populous is a populous that can’t be simply managed or manipulated. We know this based mostly on the connections between recidivism and books. We know this based mostly on how studying will increase empathy and a number of literacies and demanding considering.

We know this based mostly on the sorts of books being ripped from cabinets proper now and the rhetoric round them. “Critical Race Theory,” and “Social Emotional Learning,” and “Comprehensive Sexuality [sic] Education” are all dog-whistles for the thought of considering with out being instructed what to assume. Books that don’t paint a cheerful, colourful picture to cowl up the lies and misinformation perpetuated all through historical past are uncomfortable for these in energy to take a seat with as a result of they shine a lightweight on how they earned that energy.

One of a very powerful payments associated to guide bans floated on the nationwide degree this 12 months can also be one which has acquired little consideration: The Prison Libraries Act. U.S. Representatives Emanuel Cleaver, II (D-MO), Sheila Jackson Lee (D-TX), and Shontel Brown (D-OH) proposed the invoice in April, which might authorize $60,000,000 over six years for state prisons to supply library assets and providers — certainly, this isn’t nearly dropping tons of books into the prisons and transferring on. Trained professionals can be there to assist individuals use the academic and leisure assets. The Act would additionally assist construct highly effective coalitions between prisons and the native libraries of their group.

The Prison Libraries Act bridges the hole between work being accomplished on the bottom for colleges and libraries, and that’s being accomplished for prisons. Right now, it continues to take a seat within the House Judiciary Committee, however it’s primed for the 2023-2024 legislative season.

If you imagine within the rights of all to learn, then that extends, too, to what continues to occur in prisons throughout the nation. The similar goes within the different course: when you care about jail censorship, you then additionally care about what’s (or is just not!) taking place in colleges and public libraries.

Now is the time to work collectively.

Last week was PEN America’s Prison Banned Books Week, and throughout the online, there was super writing on the subject. It appears becoming to focus on that in a giant roundup.

Prison Banned Books Week News and Stories Worth Reading

PEN America’s full, new report, “Reading Between The Bars” is a superb have a look at the widespread actuality of carceral censorship. Some of the massive takeaways are how the pandemic elevated jail censorship by eradicating extra books from entry, administration inside prisons continues to obscure how widespread censorship is, and the inclusion of a database of books banned in numerous state prisons–this final piece comes with a number of caveats, all of that are specified by the report and which reemphasize the prior factors. Tens of 1000’s of books are banned in prisons.
There is an unimaginable collection of items printed in The Boston Globe to spend time with. First: I’m a prisoner combating guide censorship. Here’s why our entry to books issues.
More at The Boston Globe, Ban the Bans: A higher technique to rid racism in jail.
Also, at The Boston Globe, In solitary confinement, banned books are a lifeline. This line: “Like it or not, I’m a role model for my fellow inmates. I won’t apologize for valuing a good book.”
“On the day I return, Kaba admits the interactive part of the installation is “kind of a trick question.” Every one of many books that had been in George Jackson’s cell would possible be censored at the moment, she tells me. “The prison of 1971 is not the prison of 2023,” she says. “The prison of 2023, in most ways, is worse than the prison of 1971. Worse in terms of surveillance, worse in terms of control, worse in terms of what people can say.”” From In These Times‘s story titled “Prison Itself Is Censorship”: Mariame Kaba on the Freedom to Read.
The Marshall Project continues to be a premier place to study concerning the U.S. jail and (in)justice system, so naturally, their work is essential throughout and nicely past Prison Banned Books Week. Continue studying with Many Prisons Restrict Books to Stop Drug Smuggling. Critics Say It Doesn’t Work.
From late September is that this piece in Esquire about what it’s wish to be a journalist in jail–a renaissance taking place that you could be not even find out about as a result of that’s what prisons need to squash.
Also, late final month, a have a look at the “technology” that these experiencing incarceration might have entry to. It’s horrible, glitchy, and prices some huge cash.

I needed to finish this roundup with a bit printed earlier earlier this 12 months by Gretchen Sterba. When Illinois banned guide bans, activists rightly famous that that is restricted to colleges and public libraries. This piece covers that and why reform of jail censorship is crucial each in Illinois and past. Though a drop within the bucket, simply two weeks in the past, Illinois’s Secretary of State and State Librarian Alexi Giannoulias introduced that after a six-year hiatus, the state’s 28 prisons would every be receiving $15,000 for his or her libraries.