Staff votes have all been collected, and we’ve got selected our high three story & narrative video games of 2023. These shouldn’t be an excessive amount of of a shocker when you have been following our critiques, however paying credit score to the perfect of the perfect in 2023 continues to be essential.
For many gamers, the story of a sport is simply as essential because the gameplay, if no more essential, so we wished to look again and the perfect this yr needed to supply.
2nd Runner-Up: Marvel’s Spider-Man 2

Writer Nick Rivera: At this level, it’s no secret that Spider-Man 2 was nominated for seven Game Awards and didn’t win a single one. In a yr of 100+ hour campaigns, Spider-Man 2’s was definitely concise, however it hit many of the factors many gamers have been hoping it could.
Spider-Man 2 had rather a lot of new content material being integrated to maintain it recent, however it was additionally serving as a sequel for 2 separate video games. While Miles Morales was shorter than the preliminary Spider-Man sport, it felt like Spider-Man 2 may have benefited from being longer and additional fleshing out extra of the characters from each entries and letting the story circulate a bit extra naturally.
Insomniac pulled from a big selection of Spider-Man content material, and so they did a tasteful job of conserving issues recent whereas additionally sustaining the familiarity that makes the viewers love these tales within the first place. The story felt like a true-to-heart Spider-Man sport, however it’s in two completely different niches, that are each what retains it so celebrated whereas conserving it from being better.
At its core, Spider-Man 2 is a comic book e book title, which could be sufficient to discourage gamers who merely aren’t , to not point out being a sequel. On high of that, it’s a PS5 unique, instantly leaving out gamers on different platforms and PS4. Compare that to video games like Alan Wake 2 and Baldur’s Gate 3, and it turns into clear that it simply didn’t have the chops to face up in a yr full of heavyweights.
Runner-Up: Alan Wake 2

Writer Cameron Waldrop: The first Alan Wake was launched 13 years in the past, and in that point interval, Remedy Entertainment actually honed its craft. The video games that adopted Alan Wake constructed upon its core concepts, providing well-crafted characters and paranormal intrigue. The Alan Wake character even surfaced in Control to present followers a style of the place the character has been after sinking into the Dark Place.
All of this mixed into making Alan Wake 2 virtually like assembly an previous buddy once more after a very long time. The first second Saga Anderson picks up a Manuscript Page and Alan Wake narrates feels so acquainted that you just’re hooked on the thriller of the story earlier than it. Experiencing the story from two completely different factors of view permits it to breathe and preserve you in your toes.
Though there’s a clear delineation between what’s the actual world and the Dark Place, watching issues combine and switch places every thing the wrong way up for in all probability the perfect horror story that 2023 needed to supply. Plus, the sport is aware of when to interrupt the narrative and allow you to run round an precise live performance, and that’s extraordinarily commendable.
Winner: Baldur’s Gate 3

Writer Jake Su: When it involves storytelling through the medium of video video games, there isn’t actually a set strategy to go about issues. There’s at all times the hero’s journey, an apparent penchant for evil, or often, someplace in between. For Larian Studios’ Baldur’s Gate 3, gamers are given the choice to go the place their coronary heart needs, with no restrictions on the size of morality, whereas the narrative evolves and works along with your choices. Lesser video games have buckled beneath that promise, however not Baldur’s Gate 3.
All of it’s only enhanced by some of the best-written characters in gaming historical past, interval. More than simply vessels that allow your individual adventures, these are people with their very own emotions, agendas, and motivations, making them distinctive and memorable proper right down to the very finish. More importantly, they may develop alongside the participant, reflecting the values that you just maintain expensive, and ensuring the world sees it clearly whereas both becoming a member of the trigger or staying out of the best way.
This is a role-playing expertise that lives as much as the identify, the place the story takes you from ridiculous to superior throughout hours and hours spent on this wealthy world, dropped at life with wonderful writing and even higher characters. The breadth of adventures and storytelling on present are astounding, full of choices huge and small that might very nicely have main ramifications down the road, or not. Such as in life, you by no means know the place a selection will lead, and that may be a good idea realized in BG3 again and again, making it a story that’s actually your individual.
Discussion about this post