Rachel Aviv’s first ebook explores questions of self-knowledge and psychological well being, topics she’s beforehand examined in her award-winning journalism for The New Yorker. Strangers to Ourselves: Unsettled Minds and the Stories That Make Us is a shocking ebook, providing delicate case histories of individuals whose experiences of psychological sickness exceed the boundaries of psychiatric terminology, analysis and therapy.
Aviv begins together with her personal expertise as a 6-year-old who stopped consuming or ingesting, for causes she will be able to not keep in mind. She was ultimately recognized with anorexia, the youngest little one within the U.S. to obtain such a analysis, and hospitalized for “failure to eat.” At the hospital, she met anorexic ladies twice her age and discovered to mimic their methods for losing a few pounds. But which got here first: the analysis or her signs? This misfit between psychiatric terminology and lived expertise is the core difficulty driving Aviv’s subsequent chapters.
Western psychiatry has an extended historical past of ignoring how points of racial violence and systemic oppression drive psychological sickness. Aviv’s reporting on Naomi, a girl experiencing psychosis, grounds Naomi’s psychological sickness within the intergenerational trauma she has skilled as a Black lady, which has been largely ignored by the establishments which have provided her therapy. Western psychiatry, as developed inside a white European framework, additionally fails to account for cultural distinction, as within the case of Bapu, a religious Hindu. Bapu’s mystical visions of ecstatic union with Krishna could possibly be lowered to signs of schizophrenia, however to categorize them as such can be to ignore how Bapu herself interprets these visions and the way they’re understood by different Hindu worshippers.
Other chapters present how painfully restricted and limiting psychiatric language is when measured towards an individual’s personal sense of themself, a urgent difficulty within the context of the overmedication of younger individuals. When adolescents are prescribed a number of drugs for nervousness and melancholy, they threat—as in Aviv’s closing case historical past—limiting their self-definition to the diagnoses they’ve acquired.
Strangers to Ourselves is a compassionate and vital exploration of the complicated relationship between how we perceive ourselves and the way psychiatric diagnoses outline us.
Discussion about this post