THIS WEEK: The Man of Steel’s return tour of Earth continues with the Superman: Kal-El Returns Special.
Note: the evaluations beneath include spoilers. If you need a fast, spoiler-free purchase/go advice on the comics in query, try the backside of the article for our remaining verdict.
Superman: Kal-El Returns Special #1
Writers: Mark Waid, Sina Grace, Marv Wolfman, and Alex Segura
Artists: Clayton Henry, Dean Haspiel, Jack Herbert, and Fico Ossio
Colorists: Marcelo Maiolo, Trish Mulvihill, Alex Guimarâes, and Lee Loughridge
Letterer: Dave Sharpe
Cover Artist: Dan Mora
It’s simple to overlook that Superman went wherever. Yes, the Warworld Saga storyline in Action Comics noticed Kal-El go away Earth with a crew of handpicked heroes in order to liberate the titular Warworld from the tyranny of Mongul. That storyline lasted a 12 months and a half and impacted all of the Superman titles, with Jon Kent moving into the position in his personal Earth-bound solo collection. But exterior of these books, the authentic recipe Superman by no means actually went wherever. He nonetheless appeared in the pages of Justice League, as much as and together with the “Death of the Justice League” main into Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths. He’s additionally been showing repeatedly in Batman/Superman: World’s Finest, although that collection is about in the previous. This isn’t like when Superman died 30 years in the past, the place the character really disappeared from all of Superman’s books for a quantity of months. He’s been round. Still, granting the premise that he hasn’t been, this week’s Superman: Kal-El Returns Special incorporates a quartet of tales showcasing the Man of Steel’s relationships with household, buddies, and the world in the wake of his return to Earth.
The challenge kicks off with a narrative from World’s Finest scribe Mark Waid and artists Clayton Henry and Marcelo Maiolo that includes, appropriately sufficient, Superman’s reunion with Batman. Of all the tales in the particular this one is the most enjoyable, as Waid brings in parts of DC canon each well-known and obscure to inform a story in which the duo faces a foe they’ve by no means met earlier than (no less than, so far as we all know, although an editor’s notice signifies they could have). Henry and Maiolo are tasked with illustrating some off-the-wall imagery, they usually achieve this with aplomb, whereas nonetheless grounding the story firmly in the heroes at its middle.
Next up is a Jimmy Olsen-centric story from Sina Grace, Dean Haspiel, and Trish Mulvihill. Grace’s script captures the distinctive relationship between Jimmy and Superman superbly, with only a contact of the oddball absurdity Jimmy is thought for thrown in for good measure. It’s a candy story about Jimmy making an attempt to take simply the proper photograph to seize the second of Superman’s return. Unfortunately the place this story fails is in Haspiel’s artwork. The crux of the story is the energy of imagery, and Haspiel’s illustration of Jimmy’s highly effective picture simply feels lackluster. The framing of it’s boring, and it’s simply super-static. It’s a disappointing finish to what’s in any other case a extremely satisfying story.
The remaining two tales in the particular are easy and total very satisfying. Marv Wolfman returns to Superman and to a personality he helped revamp in the late ‘80s, Lex Luthor, with a story illustrated by Jack Herbert and Alex Guimarâes. Lex has been out of the spotlight for a while, and this story was a strong reminder of just what a great foil the character is for Superman and for the rest of his family. The anchor story is a Justice League tale from Alex Segura, Fico Ossio, and Lee Loughridge. It’s a pleasant reunion story that spotlights quite a bit of the themes which have been at play in the DCU over the previous 12 months or so, specifically that of legacy and the position the Justice League performs in the superhero group. It’s additionally tasked with bridging the hole between the Warworld Saga and the Death of the Justice League, which it does as neatly as attainable.
I’m unsure that the Superman: Kal-El Returns Special is essentially an important learn, nevertheless it’s quite a bit of enjoyable. The lead Batman team-up story is price the value of admission alone, and the relaxation of the challenge’s tales do an endearing job of showcasing Superman’s place in the world and amongst his household, buddies, and enemies. As tie-in specials go, you may’t actually ask for something extra.
Final Verdict: BROWSE.
Round-Up
- This week’s Round-Up’s only a fast have a look at a pair of different noteworthy releases. First, Justice Society of America #1 is traditional Geoff Johns, however not the manner that Stargirl: The Lost Children #1 was traditional Johns. This picks up the place the New Golden Age one-shot left off, and is Johns again on his bullshit, casually melding Earth-2 continuity into the most important DCU timeline, jettisoning tales from different creators that he’s not in, introducing a bunch of new characters, then killing them off horrifically. The attention-grabbing half of the story is the final web page, so hopefully future points shall be higher. They would nearly must be. At least Mikel Janín and Jordie Bellaire‘s artwork is nice as normal.
- Blue Beetle: Graduation Day #1, on the different hand, is a good kickoff to Jaime Reyes’s newest journey. Josh Trujillo, Adrián Gutiérrez, and Will Quintana do a improbable job introducing Blue Beetle and his world, and the motion of the story grabs readers instantly and doesn’t let go. It’s a narrative that steeped in Jaime’s historical past however incorporates it easily and apparently. Excited to see the place this collection goes.
Miss any of our earlier evaluations? Check out our full archive!
Discussion about this post