Although Eren Yeager and Light Yagami are from two separate worlds, the pair share a standard purpose of desirous to stability the books of an unjust system. More typically than not, this typically results in demise; therefore, the titling of the Death Note collection — and Attack on Titan is, in fact, no stranger to that idea as nicely.
But now the query stays: Who is the true evil protagonist between the 2 legendary anime? Could it’s the notorious Kira, or will the brand new Founding Titan wielder be the one who reigns supreme? The solely solution to decide the winner of this battle is by their arc as an entire and the reasoning behind their sinister acts.
Let’s begin with their origins and the way the characters have been impressed to trigger the downfall of their respective worlds. In our introduction to Light, we see an excellent teenager who’s extremely bored along with his life, virtually making it too simple for Ryuk to tempt him with the Death Note. His first intuition is to exterminate all of the filthy criminals of the world, which could possibly be seen as a heroic act.
However, you may say the identical for Showtime’s TV collection most important protagonist, Dexter, who has the identical ideology as Light. Given that Yagami already has tendencies of a blatant serial killer, issues don’t look too good for our genius boy marvel. His expressions additionally don’t do him justice as a result of, nicely, he simply appears evil (a minimum of, that’s what I’m seeing.)
When it involves Eren’s reasoning, he didn’t outright begin with the necessity to kill, versus Light. Yes, he needed to eradicate the Titans as a result of demise of his mom and the remainder of the Shiganshina residents, but it surely wasn’t one thing he initially started with. It was a perception that was developed all through the years till it will definitely got here into full fruition the second he noticed the dystopian future from Historia’s hand.
So, we have now Light, who instantly offers in to darkish urges proper from the beginning, whereas Eren is extra of a gradual burn. Nevertheless, you’ll be able to nonetheless contemplate the truth that Yeager’s evilness was with him all alongside, however actually, I don’t assume this darkness was there till the top of AoT Season 3 and the remainder of Season 4.
Viewers can even acknowledge the truth that Eren is aware of that he can not change the longer term, as he’s tried this earlier than, and he doesn’t essentially have a alternative in his selections. It’s nonetheless morally fallacious to do, but it’s difficult to understand should you have been in his sneakers.
Beyond the reasoning, we have to look at the 2 characters’ guilt, given that almost all true villains don’t expertise this emotion. Light initially feels this after he commits “murder” with the Death Note, however then he finally disregards it as one thing that’s proper and might solely be achieved by him, the good ruler of the world.
While Eren could appear to be he’s the identical approach, along with his a number of situations of heartless feelings, he’s proven his guilt just a few occasions in Attack on Titan’s remaining season. You can see an ideal instance of this when he apologizes to the younger Ramzi, realizing he can be the one liable for his demise. It doesn’t exempt him from his actions, but it surely does present his compunction for it.
The solely time I’ve actually seen Yagami show some type of unhappiness was throughout his dad’s demise. Even then, I’m not totally positive if the tears have been actual since he did say he was utilizing it as a tactic to get his father to jot down within the Death Note.
Now that we’ve reviewed their reasoning and guilt, let’s discuss concerning the horrible issues they’ve really achieved. In hindsight, we are able to see that Eren is the winner right here for probably the most atrocious acts since he, you recognize… worn out 80 % of the world via the Rumbling. Based on this alone, I’d say Yeager can be thought of anime’s most evil most important protagonist.
On the opposite hand, we are able to’t solely rely upon this reasoning, as loads of different components can nonetheless come into play. Light isn’t even scott-free both attributable to his linkage to an unlimited quantity of deaths. According to the followers, Yagami has roughly killed greater than 200,000 individuals with the Death Note. Of course, that’s nothing in comparison with Eren’s horrible feats, however we should always nonetheless preserve it in thoughts.
When all of it comes all the way down to it, Eren and Light’s remaining moments may help us decide the result for the true evil most important protagonist by wanting into their impression on different characters. True villains, each fictional and non-fiction, have a tendency to not have anybody grieve for them until a gaggle or a person believes of their corrupt ideology.
Once Light reaches the top of the street, the remaining members of the Task Force really feel betrayed and switch towards him, just like what occurs to Eren. However, the 2 characters’ deaths are considerably completely different regardless of their shared occurrences. While Yagami dies alone, Yeager continues to be surrounded by these he loves regardless of what he’s achieved. His pals additionally don’t outrightly take his facet after his demise, and extra so come to phrases with understanding why he did what he did.
We can see that throughout the Attack on Titan epilogue scenes, all his pals go to him incessantly. For me, somebody actually evil wouldn’t have individuals nonetheless caring for him, like Eren has, which is the polar reverse of Light’s journey. No one actually mourns him, apart from Misa Amane, and that proves to me that Yagami is the clear winner because the evilest most important protagonist.
Everything about Light has all the time been linked to morally fallacious acts, ranging from the present’s starting and proper till the top. He’s proven no guilt all through the collection and by no means cares about his actions or how they have an effect on everybody round him. That doesn’t imply he’s a poorly written character; it simply proves he’s the true evil one right here.
At the top of the day, you’ll be able to type your personal opinions on this matter since Eren might undoubtedly maintain the villainous mantle from particular views, primarily attributable to his half in his mom’s demise. Nevertheless, it’s not like Light was that harmless in his personal father’s demise, in order that’s not an enormous leap both.
We might most likely commute for an eternity on who’s probably the most evil anime most important protagonist, however I imagine what actually issues is the impression these two collection have made. I imply, simply take a look at how Death Note remains to be talked about even immediately, no matter its launch all these years in the past. The identical might most likely be stated for Attack on Titan sooner or later via its devoted fanbase.
There will possible be extra evil protagonists to come back, and it demonstrates the continued adjustments to the traditional heroic most important protagonist. It definitely retains the fun going and solidifies that storytelling in anime is genuinely exceptional, irrespective of how depraved it could be.
About the creator
Discussion about this post