Jennifer Lopez has been busy. In case you missed it, the Puerto Rican singer, dancer, and actor launched not one however three complementary tasks to kick off the yr. There’s her “This Is Me . . . Now” album; a video companion/musical to mentioned album, “This Is Me . . . Now: A Love Story”; and a documentary that dives into mentioned love story, “The Greatest Love Story Never Told.” It was an bold enterprise, little doubt. And one which has her being dragged throughout TikTok, Instagram, and X (previously Twitter).
Part of the controversy lies in how Lopez represents herself and her native borough of the Bronx. In one scene from the documentary, Lopez tussles her curly hair whereas trying within the mirror and says, “It reminds me, like, when I was 16 in the Bronx, running up and down the block. Crazy little girl who used to fucking be wild and no limits, all dreams.” TikTok shortly jumped on this small clip, with many customers commenting on how contrived the scene felt. One person famous it allegedly took quite a few takes to get the completed shot. From there, it wasn’t lengthy earlier than social media began to mine Lopez’s previous interviews for any trace of inauthenticity.
In a resurfaced clip from Vogue’s “73 Questions” collection, Lopez shares her childhood bodega order of “ham and cheese on a roll with an orange drink . . . and a small bag of chips.” This clip, too, has been flamed on social media as New Yorkers demand to know precisely what orange drink Lopez is referring to. Others have remarked it is such a generic order that Lopez cannot be as bodega-bred as she claims.
And then, after all, there’s the nail within the coffin: an previous clip from 2014 making the rounds on social media that reveals Lopez pulling as much as her previous home in Castle Hill, and the present resident having completely no concept who she is.
It’s not that Lopez is not from the Bronx — after all, she is. No one can take that away from her. It’s that the picture she portrays, one in all a tried-and-true Bronx lady who made it to Hollywood whereas staying true to her roots, comes off as disingenuous. Many suppose she’s utilizing the borough for relevance in an age that values authenticity greater than something. But how did she change into so seemingly disconnected from the folks she supposedly represents?
Growing up in a Puerto Rican family meant Lopez might do no unsuitable. She was the Fly Girl who made it massive. She was Selena. And when her debut album, “On the 6,” dropped, my mother had it on repeat, singing alongside to each phrase. For my mother, Lopez symbolized success. For many heads from that era, that is what success was — not a lot repping your hood, however representing the truth that you made it out of your hood.
Today, nonetheless, that is not sufficient. That’s why Lopez’s actions are sometimes perceived as self-serving. In half, it is a generational distinction. This is evidenced by the truth that so few of her latest critics knew what she meant by “orange drink.” For the file, I’m fairly positive she was referencing the 25-cent “quarter waters” that have been a staple of bodegas again within the ’90s (you would be hard-pressed to search out them now). They did not have a correct identify; you simply requested for the colour. But, bodega order apart, the truth that Lopez needed to rebrand her tour amid slowing ticket gross sales reveals how a lot public opinion has waned for a star who as soon as offered out Vegas residencies with frequency.
In this gentle, it is unsurprising that folks from the group and even her followers are skeptical of how she reps the Bronx — an try and delay the solar setting on an unbelievable 30-year profession and energize the plenty. But it isn’t sufficient to assert NYC as your birthright and anticipate New Yorkers to point out up. Here, belief and loyalty are received the arduous method. You need to put the town in your again, elevate it, and actively take part within the tradition.
Cardi B made headlines when she donated $100,000 to her previous center college within the Bronx. Fat Joe helped arrange a fundraiser for households affected by the 2022 Twin Parks fireplace, and he is well-known for routinely giving again to the group. And J Lo? Well, that is the factor. She has. In 2014, she introduced a partnership with Montefiore Medical Center within the Bronx to ascertain The Center for a Healthy Childhood, which aimed to enhance youngsters’s well being and general diet within the surrounding communities.
But for many people, the occasional philanthropic stint is not sufficient. And the truth that it has been 10 years since her final main contribution to the borough does not assist Lopez’s case. Neither does the truth that she danced her approach to an appearing profession, singing profession, and tens of millions of {dollars} alongside the way in which, however she hasn’t opened a single dance academy to assist others do the identical. I feel a Jennifer Lopez-branded dance academy within the coronary heart of Castle Hill could be a no brainer and would assist her enhance her present standing in the neighborhood.
That being mentioned, Lopez is not obligated to fulfill anybody’s expectations however her personal. And there are many A-list New Yorkers who do much less for his or her respective boroughs and are topic to far much less criticism. At the top of the day, nonetheless, Lopez is exclusive in that she understands and cashes in on the social clout that comes with being from the Bronx. She understands that it distinguishes her from nearly all of the Hollywood elite — she’s somebody who is not imagined to have a seat on the desk, but now enjoys the identical privileges as her silver-spoon counterparts.
I as soon as had a good friend inform me that the hood is one thing nobody can take from you. It’s hardwired into you, no matter what you obtain. The classes the streets train are classes for all times. I actually consider that. And I’m positive Lopez does, too. In her eyes, she’ll at all times be Jenny from the block, no matter what any of us need to say.
But I additionally consider there is not any such factor as enjoying each side. As somebody who has slowly watched their neighborhood disappear due to gentrification and has had the panorama of his recollections shift with every passing day, I want I had the cash to do one thing about it. And if I ever discovered myself in that place, able to provide again, I might.
Miguel Machado s a journalist with experience within the intersection of Latine identification and tradition. He does every part from unique interviews with Latin music artists to opinion items on points which might be related to the group, private essays tied to his Latinidad, and thought items and options regarding Puerto Rico and Puerto Rican tradition.
Discussion about this post