A killer went after transgender ladies, main a grieving father to understand too late that he ought to have accepted his daughter for who she was.
Law & Order: SVU Season 24 Episode 8 concerned violence towards trans ladies and unsupportive mother and father.
It had a heartwarming ending regardless of some flaws within the story.
As a transgender particular person, I’ve blended emotions about some of these tales.
On the one hand, violence towards transgender folks is a critical situation that must be mentioned. But too typically, trans persons are ONLY included in exhibits like SVU when they’re victims of violent crime, and that is not cool both.
Although this story fell into the entice of solely together with transgender victims, it additionally had many trans-supportive features. I appreciated the give attention to Detective McDaniels’ rising consciousness that he missed out on an genuine relationship together with his youngster as a result of he couldn’t settle for her as a girl.
I could not settle for Ada for who she was, and that was my loss. I by no means acquired to know her.
McDaniels
Instead of making an attempt to empower a rape sufferer, Benson needed to encourage the grieving father to simply accept who his daughter had been in life and return her issues in order that he may get justice for her.
Their dialog after Cora’s testimony was highly effective. McDaniels was disgusted by what Cora had suffered and what he now realized Ava needed to have suffered. He felt responsible and ashamed of getting tampered with the crime scene in order that different cops could not chuckle at his useless youngster.
McDaniel: If I’d solely left every part alone, perhaps Cora would not have been attacked.
Benson: You know, Cora wanted a father. You can nonetheless be that for Ada. You can name her by the title she selected.
McDaniel: I used to be not an excellent particular person.
Benson: So be a greater one.
But as emotional as his breakthrough was, it was nonetheless sullied considerably by the truth that he did not need to settle for Ada’s gender id till he heard about one other trans girl’s ache.
It’s higher late than by no means, and he wanted to listen to his daughter’s expertise from somebody like her. Character-wise, it made sense.
But writers should additionally take into account the larger image and the messages they ship. The general message about acceptance being essential was nice, however Ada and Cora did not have way more to their characters than being victims, and that wasn’t so good.
On exhibits like SVU, there’s typically little time to get to know the victims and their lives exterior of being attacked. In this case, they may have had the identical story with out lowering Ada to a sufferer.
If Ada hadn’t died, there would have been no want for Cora to be attacked. Ada may have struggled with the query of whether or not to maneuver ahead along with her case whereas her father wished it stored secret that she’d been “in drag” on the time of the assault.
That may need been an much more highly effective story. Instead of realizing too late that he by no means knew his daughter, McDaniels may have redeemed himself and discovered to simply accept her whereas she was alive. And one other trans girl wouldn’t have needed to have been became a sufferer to assist wake him up.
Cora’s testimony introduced up some essential points, although.
The protection lawyer’s cross-examination was obnoxious. First of all, has she by no means heard of cross-gender hormones? Of course, Cora would not have the identical physique and muscle construction as she did earlier than she started her medical transition. (This foolish argument can also be the idea for eager to bar trans ladies from ladies’s sports activities.)
Worse, she requested if Cora “identified as a man” when she was a wrestler. This put Cora in an not possible place.
Most trans folks do not determine as their start gender pre-transition. But if Cora stated she did not determine as a person in these days, the jury would probably not perceive, and the protection lawyer may paint her as “confused” to attempt to get them to ignore her testimony.
This doubly sucks as a result of speaking about pre-transition life can generally harm trans folks’s psychological well being, particularly if they’re misgendered or pressured to recollect residing as a gender that did not match them.
The protection lawyer’s different competition that it was a consensual roleplay was particularly ridiculous in gentle of the opposite questions she requested. In that scenario, saying “no” or “stop” could be ineffective as a result of it could be assumed it was a part of the sport.
If it have been really a consensual “non-consensual” roleplay, Cora would have used a secure phrase or phrase. If that was the protection lawyer’s argument, she should not have bothered asking why Cora did not say no.
The protection lawyer’s annoying questions are the identical ones that protection attorneys typically ask rape victims. For some purpose, there’s this concept that if the particular person did not say no, it magically makes a non-consensual encounter consensual, and rapists’ attorneys typically attempt to paint the victims as dishonest or untrustworthy.
Still, it was doubly annoying that these questions additionally referred to as Cora’s gender id into query. The “rough sex” protection additionally performed into stereotypes of trans ladies as males who like to decorate as ladies for sexual causes.
Rollins did a wonderful job of explaining the trans expertise and why some folks cannot cope with it. She’ll be effectively ready if any of her women ever come out as trans or non-binary.
Rollins: I noticed you mirroring his language. Calling him Aiden.
Benson: He wasn’t going to speak to me if I used the unsuitable pronoun.
Rollins: It wasn’t unsuitable in response to Aiden.
She additionally bristled at Benson’s misgendering Ada when speaking to Ada’s father. I understood the place Benson was coming from, although. You cannot transfer a dad or mum from completely non-accepting to accepting in a single transfer.
When I used to work on an LGBT disaster line, I typically needed to do one thing comparable when mother and father who weren’t accepting but referred to as to ask for recommendation about coping with their youngsters’ transition.
I’d typically use the kid’s start title after which, after constructing belief, start to encourage the dad or mum to make use of the kid’s chosen title and pronoun.
Rollins is getting set to maneuver on from SVU. I’ll miss her, particularly after this final episode.
Here are just a few different odds and ends about this story:
-
Ada’s pal was named Brain Donnelly, and McDaniels stated the household was all criminals. Was Brian associated to Frank Donnelly, the corrupt cop that killed himself after Stabler uncovered his wrongdoings on Law & Order: Organized Crime Season 2? -
Did anybody else discover it bizarre for Carisi to query his fiancee on the stand? I half anticipated that protection lawyer to make an enormous deal out of it. -
Fin and Muncy’s relationship is coming alongside, although I may have sworn Fin already warned Muncy that he’d inform Benson if she disobeyed orders once more. And sorry, bro, however I like pineapple pizza.
What about you, Law & Order: SVU fanatics? What did you consider Rollins’ penultimate episode and the way in which this episode handled violence towards trans folks?
Hit the massive, blue SHOW COMMENTS button to tell us. And do not forget you may watch Law & Order: SVU on-line.
Law & Order: SVU airs on NBC on Thursdays at 9 PM EST / PST. The subsequent new episode will air on December 8, 2022.
Jack Ori is a senior employees author for TV Fanatic. His debut younger grownup novel, Reinventing Hannah, is out there on Amazon. Follow him on Twitter.
Discussion about this post