Writers and actors spent the summer time trying to find elevated residuals for streaming exhibits and so they had been considerably profitable. Both the WGA and SAG-AFTRA secured success-based bonuses for sequence at Netflix, Amazon, Apple, Disney+, Max, Peacock and Paramount+ as a part of their shiny three-year agreements.
But what does it imply in follow? What exhibits will actually nab the bonus checks? How a lot will they make and what comes subsequent?
It’s clear that Netflix’s greatest sequence resembling Stranger Things, Wednesday and Bridgerton can be rewarded underneath the brand new system. But sources and specialists advised Deadline that it’s doubtless that various different exhibits resembling Peacock’s Natasha Lyonne-fronted Poker Face and Disney+’s Marvel sequence Secret Invasion starring Samuel L. Jackson can be shut to creating the lower by way of the revamped mannequin.
On the opposite hand, it may be onerous for exhibits on different streamers resembling Amazon’s Prime Video to return near the brand new targets on condition that the corporate has practically 170 million subscribers, most of that are doubtless extra all for free transport than watching The Peripheral.
These good points are only a begin, in keeping with SAG-AFTRA’s National Executive Director and Chief Negotiator Duncan Crabtree-Ireland, who advised Deadline that the guild would look to barter decrease boundaries to entry for bonuses and better transparency in future negotiations.
Both guilds set their sights on a success-based residual for streaming titles from day one in all talks in an effort to deal with the dwindling payouts their members are receiving within the streaming period, however the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers was reluctant to agree.
The WGA’s contract, which was secured in September, included a bonus construction that will set off an extra fee for any title that met a particular viewership threshold.
While SAG-AFTRA, which is ready for the outcomes of its ratification vote December 5, had initially hoped for extra, it in the end agreed in its tentative settlement to a bonus construction just like the WGA’s.
This bonus construction might not have been precisely what both union had in thoughts once they entered negotiations, but it surely’s a begin.
“I would say the studios didn’t go hugely far with what they were doing. They kept it in some way in a box, and they kept it to a result that ultimately will not really pull in a huge number of shows,” one high agent advised Deadline. “The splashiest of shows are really the ones [that will be rewarded].”
HOW DOES IT WORK?
In order to be eligible for the bonus, a title should obtain sufficient home “views” in its first 90 days to be equal to twenty% of the streaming service’s home subscribers. “Views” are outlined because the hours considered divided by the runtime of a undertaking, quite than the true variety of distinctive accounts that work together with the title.
For the WGA, the credited author for every episode will obtain an extra 50% of their fastened home and international residual if the present meets the above standards.
For SAG-AFTRA, any title that surpasses the viewership threshold will set off a fee to every principal performer equal to 100% of the fastened residual. However, the performer will solely obtain 75% of that fee. The different 25% can be funneled right into a fund managed by each SAG-AFTRA and AMPTP trustees to be distributed among the many remainder of the union’s members.
Since it was unveiled, this language raised questions as to how this fund would function. As David Offenberg, leisure finance professor at Loyola Marymount University, defined, “It could be used for literally anything that SAG does.”
By the guild’s estimation, the brand new bonus construction will yield roughly $40 million per yr, translating to about $10M annually distributed by way of the fund.
According to Crabtree-Ireland, the fund can be “for other actors who work in made-for-streaming content that’s exhibited on those same platforms.” But, per the tentative MBA, any performer who receives the success-based efficiency bonus themselves is not going to be eligible.
“The intent is to broaden this so that it’s not just the folks who worked on the most successful programs [who benefit], but also people who worked on other programs that are on the platform, but which maybe didn’t rise to that level of hit status that triggered the 20% threshold,” he advised Deadline.
Distribution tips and eligibility can be decided by the trustees, as soon as they’re appointed. So far, SAG-AFTRA and the AMPTP haven’t mentioned these specifics, in keeping with Crabtree-Ireland.
WHAT SHOWS WILL BE REWARDED?
It’s troublesome to find out precisely what number of creatives will profit from these performance-based bonuses, as a result of the streaming companies don’t at present launch intensive viewership information.
Netflix solely self-reports international viewership for its high titles weekly, so it isn’t doable to find out the scale of the home viewers for any given title. On the opposite hand, whereas Nielsen reviews viewership information for the U.S., its weekly reviews don’t separate viewing by season.
There are the apparent winners like Stranger Things, Wednesday, Bridgerton, and mainly something that’s amongst Netflix’s hottest titles of all time. But calculating which different exhibits might need met the edge is trickier.
Poker Face (Peacock)
Peacock
Peacock’s Poker Face seems to be one such sequence eligible for the bonus. Based on Nielsen information from the sequence’ first two weeks of availability, the sequence tallied about 4.5 million “views.” This equates to round 15% of Peacock’s 28 million subscribers, which signifies that the sequence was capable of surpass the 20% threshold by the point it had completed rolling out 5 weeks later.
Disney+’s Secret Invasion, which per Nielsen managed about 7 million home “views” over its six-week rollout interval, is one other title that appears to have made the lower as that determine equals practically 16% of Disney+’s 44.5M home subscribers with six weeks left to depend.
However, it’s tougher to calculate for different streamers. For occasion, the one two Paramount+ originals to make it onto the Nielsen charts are Star Trek: Strange New Worlds and 1923. The Yellowstone spinoff was solely on the charts for one week, not sufficient information to find out if the sequence can be eligible for the bonus. The Star Trek sequence launched its second season this yr and, since Nielsen doesn’t report information primarily based on a single season, it isn’t doable to find out how a lot viewership got here from Season 2, which is the season that will be eligible for the bonus.
During negotiations, the studios offered an analysis of which tasks would have certified within the final yr, in keeping with Crabtree-Ireland, who advised Deadline that SAG-AFTRA performed its personal evaluation to match with the studios’ and expanded the information to incorporate content material from the previous a number of years.
“We think we have a handle on approximately how much money would be generated from this based on the number of shows that qualify and the number of performers,” he stated. “It’s obviously not a fixed number, it’s going to depend upon how successful projects are.”
A CLOSER LOOK: WHAT IS THE POTENTIAL PAYOUT?
SAG-AFTRA calculates residuals by multiplying a performer’s whole precise compensation per episode (as much as an relevant ceiling) by two percentages — one to account for a streamer’s subscriber depend and one which depreciates primarily based on the variety of years a title has been exhibited. The streaming bonus will embrace each the international and home residual.
The potential payout for titles will range tremendously, relying on the size of this system, in addition to which streaming service it’s exhibited on.
For instance, to calculate the streaming bonus {that a} principal performer on Stranger Things 4 might need earned, you first decide the ceiling for whole precise compensation. For this sequence, that’s $4,698 for any episodes underneath 85 minutes lengthy and $5,027 for these which might be 85 minutes or longer, per the tentative MBA. Regardless of how a lot a performer makes, that is the ceiling from which residuals are calculated.
To calculate the home residual, multiply that quantity by a subscriber issue of 150% for the most important streaming companies. Then, multiply that by 45% for the primary exhibition yr. The whole home residual is both $3,171.15 or $3,393.22, relying on the episode size.
The calculation for the international residual is identical, besides the subscriber issue is 90% for the most important streamers. So, that residual is both $1,902.69 or $2,035.9 per episode, relying on the episode size. Together, these bonus funds can be $5,073.84 or $5,429.12.
Principal performers would then obtain 75% of the whole mixed payout per episode ($3,805.38 or $4,071.84), and the rest would go into the SAG-AFTRA/AMPTP-controlled fund.
The WGA makes use of an analogous method, having set residuals bases for packages which might be decided by size. For Stranger Things 4, these bases are both $30,398 or $75,000. The studio will use these residual bases to calculate a international and home residual, and the payout can be half of each of these.
To calculate the home residual, multiply the residual base by the subscriber issue, which is as soon as once more 150% for the most important streaming companies. Then, multiply that by 45% for the primary exhibition yr. That comes out to $20,518.65. Just like with SAG-AFTRA, use a 90% subscriber issue to find out the international residual. So, that residual is $12,311.19.
Since the efficiency bonus for the WGA is 50% of the international and home residual mixed, that will come out $16,415. For the lengthier episodes, it could be $40,500. These calculations are primarily based on the residual base if the story and teleplay are credited to the identical author. If they’re credited to completely different writers, the residual for every drops dramatically.
— Katie Campione
THE START OF SOMETHING NEW
There is little question these offers will pave the trail ahead for a bigger streaming compensation mannequin for creatives and elevated information transparency from the studios. However, as a number of specialists level out, the phrases are removed from excellent.
“I think the guild did a good job of opening the door. The reality is, guilds negotiate the floor,” an agent advised Deadline. “It’s up to agents and talent representatives and everybody else to push through the rest of it. The streamers have been reluctant except in the highest level of deals and individual situations to do things like this.”
As of now, the efficiency bonus solely applies to scripted, high-budget subscription video on demand (HBSVOD) titles, that means there are many different streaming titles that received’t be eligible together with actuality and low-budget titles, and titles made for ad-based video on demand companies (AVOD).
Sorry, Jury Duty, Amazon Freevee doesn’t qualify. Neither would Netflix’s well-liked actuality sequence like Love Is Blind or Selling Sunset.
For titles that do qualify, writers and principal performers will solely be eligible for one extra fee, primarily based on how the undertaking performs inside a comparatively small window after launch.
“If you look at the amount of compensation, it’s insanely small. This is effectively a second [fixed] residual,” Offenberg stated. “It’s not even that the actors get a second residual, they get 75% of the second. These are going to be super small bonuses, and we’re going to hear from some [creatives] within the next year or two about the fact that they got the bonus and it’s pathetic.”
Netflix paved the best way for this metric for use, having launched weekly hours considered for its high titles for years. Recently, the streamer up to date its self-reported metric to “views,” outlined the identical as it’s within the guilds’ contracts — hours considered divided by runtime. While it does give a broad understanding of how well-liked a sequence is, the metric comes with its personal set of stipulations.
Most notably, it doesn’t account for completion charge, a priceless information level for the streaming companies. Instead, the information assumes that each time a person watches a brand new piece of content material, they make it all through each single time. This in the end inflates distinctive views. In actuality, it’s extra doubtless that some customers are watching a number of occasions, whereas many by no means make it to the tip the primary time.
This is realistically not a quantity that streamers are prioritizing when figuring out success internally. Make no mistake, the studios are compiling intensive information behind the scenes for each title on a streaming service and assigning some kind of valuation to them, even when they’re reluctant to truly share their course of.
“It’s ironic that in a world where you actually have more information, we’re getting less information and less knowledge of what’s successful,” the agent stated. “For all we know, in the streaming world, Stranger Things is bigger than any of the [shows] we used to call the biggest hits.”
However, common viewership is a metric that can allow viewers comparisons throughout streaming and linear tv, on condition that that is how Nielsen and different third events report linear viewership. It additionally permits for continued comparability with Nielsen’s streaming information, which is reported in minutes considered.
“The reality is, there’s no perfect way to measure viewership. You don’t know how many people are in the room watching. You don’t know if they’re actually watching or if they’re folding laundry. We’re going to build human habitations on Mars before we accurately measure viewership,” Offenberg stated. “It’s just not possible. Anything that they came up with was going to be fine. It’s better than using Parrot [Analytics] data or anything like that, because this is the real data from their platform.”
We’re going to construct human habitations on Mars earlier than we precisely measure viewership. It’s simply not doable.”
LMU Professor David Offenberg
Then there’s the query about subscriber calculations themselves. For a lot of the conventional streaming companies, agreeing on home subscriber depend is comparatively simple. But what about Amazon? All Prime subscribers have entry to Amazon’s video streaming service, although that doesn’t essentially imply they’re utilizing it. According to estimates, Amazon has about 168 million U.S. subscribers, which might set a virtually inconceivable threshold for any titles to attain 20% viewership.
SAG-AFTRA and the AMPTP mentioned the problem of figuring out the subs for bundled companies like Amazon, and so they agreed to enter arbitration “should an issue arise” in figuring out what number of subscribers the service has. Deadline requested SAG-AFTRA for clarification, however the guild has but to reply.
Even on the opposite streamers, 20% of home subscribers is a reasonably excessive bar, and there are presumably not many made-for-streaming titles that will qualify.
“In theory, there’s a breakpoint in there where you can have a series that churns along at a certain number of hours and it just kind of always stays below [the threshold],” one agent famous, including that the deal is “imperfect” however opens the door for the guilds to barter a decrease barrier and better transparency sooner or later to assist paint a fuller image of success within the streaming period.
“I would definitely hope for that,” Crabtree-Ireland advised Deadline of plans for future negotiations. “That could happen in a variety of ways. The net could be wider by virtue of perhaps lowering the percentage of subscribers that a show has to get in order to qualify. The net can be cast wider by raising the percentage payments, so the money goes up, so we have more money to distribute in the bonus pool. There’s several levers that can help move in that direction, and I definitely would like to see that happen.”
SOLVING FOR ‘SUITS‘
Still, this new deal received’t reward all success. Licensed and/or acquired programming is not going to be eligible for the streaming efficiency bonus, regardless of being a buoy for each service as they construct out their authentic libraries. As streamers have grown utilizing libraries of acquired content material, the cash paid to creatives has tanked.
“Broadcast residuals were based very much on success in that if the show got reruns, and if it got syndication, then those syndication deals continued paying residuals for years and years and years,” Offenberg stated.
Case in level: Suits. The USA Network authorized drama grew to become the present of the summer time when the primary eight seasons dropped on Netflix in June. The sequence has spent months dominating Nielsen’s streaming charts and, as of the corporate’s final report, racked up greater than 45 billion minutes considered over the course of 18 weeks. Yet, creatives will nonetheless solely be paid a small share of the licensing price Netflix paid to NBCUniversal (which, contemplating that nobody foresaw this success, was not very giant).
“Sometimes the value is the platform. In this case, the winner is the platform. So how do you find a way that regardless of who the winner is, that the clients are getting paid appropriately?” the agent stated. “I think that’s really the next challenge is trying to fashion something that really matches what we’re dealing with today.”
Streamers have additionally enticed audiences with next-day streaming releases and, in some circumstances, made episodes obtainable concurrently (and even earlier than) they air on linear tv. HBO has operated this manner for years, dropping episodes of Succession, Euphoria, and so forth., on streaming as they debut on cable. Showtime has additionally adopted a mixed launch technique, providing new episodes of well-liked sequence like Yellowjackets on Paramount+ a number of days earlier than they air on the cable channel.
No matter how a lot viewership these titles carry to the streaming companies, they won’t be rewarded past the licensing price paid to the studio.
“It’s just more looking at the unique nature of streaming and finding some different ways to make sure that our clients are getting compensated for how the streamers are benefiting,” the agent added.
THE TIP OF THE ICEBERG
This is just not the tip of the street for SAG-AFTRA or the WGA, each of which can doubtless attempt to transfer the needle ahead on streaming transparency and compensation throughout the subsequent spherical of negotiations in 2026.
And the guilds aren’t alone. Much of Hollywood is pushing for extra details about how sure titles are acting on streaming.
“We can’t make choices for our clients when we don’t really understand this,” one agent stated. “That’s why I think the data point is huge. In some ways, it’s the biggest point because once we get to some common understanding or discussion around it, we can then fashion a model that makes sense around that. Right now, we’re kind of just making stuff up a bit to try to trigger some kind of gains in this area.”
As Offenberg put it, that is solely “the tip of the iceberg” by way of what information the guilds would want with a view to meaningfully put a price ticket on success.
“I think that this is more than anything a play for data transparency,” he stated. “This was a way to negotiate to get them to hand over some data. It’s not perfect … but they’re getting data. And with that data, I think they’re going to be able to negotiate for much more in the years to come.”
Discussion about this post