The Good Doctor Season 6 Episode 17 Review: Second Chances And Past Regrets

Jared beginning his residency once more was sure to be problematic.

He has far an excessive amount of information to be a first-year, particularly when he is been out within the area some time.

And on The Good Doctor Season 6 Episode 17, his first day went terribly badly due to the expectation that he maintain his mouth shut and comply with Shaun’s lead.

Shaun’s expectations had been hypocritical. Not way back, he and Glassman butted heads over Shaun altering the surgical plan and Lim’s subsequent paralysis.

Shaun nonetheless struggles with seeing different folks’s views, due to his autism. Irritatingly, he comes off as if he is all the time proper and others are all the time flawed.

But it is not that Shaun is entitled or spoiled. He has issue understanding why others suppose, really feel, and act in methods he dislikes. From his standpoint, his refusals to comply with instructions are justified, whereas Jared’s are usually not as a result of they contradict his well-thought-out opinion.

Shaun: Jared has made my job very tough.
Glassman: Shaun, sit down. When you had been a first-year resident, you would not hearken to anyone and you probably did issues your individual means. You nonetheless do. You rubbed everybody the flawed means and also you made everybody’s job tougher, particularly mine. But we gave you area to study and we realized from you too, and also you reworked your self into an asset. Okay, so Jared overstepped. Give him the area to study such as you did.

Thankfully, Glassman straightened Shaun out about this. I might hear the unexpressed triumph as he requested Shaun if Jared had modified Shaun’s surgical plan.

It will need to have taken the whole lot for Glassman to keep away from smirking as he requested that query!

Glassman is the one one who can get by way of to Shaun at instances like this. Sometimes, Shaun will not even hearken to Lea, however he’ll nearly all the time hearken to Glassman.

The two have a particular relationship, so let’s hope Glassman’s poor (in keeping with Shaun) suture approach was an anomaly and never the indication of a major problem that Shaun appears to suppose it’s!

Shaun wasn’t the one one accountable for the mess with Jared. Andrews’ directions did not assist issues any.

Andrews needed to impress upon Shaun the significance of not taking part in favorites. But his directions had been imprecise and summary; the one specifics he gave Shaun had been that he should not name Jared by his first title and that he should not show favoritism.

Leaving in too many blanks for Shaun to fill in is rarely a good suggestion. Shaun’s inside logic would not match how neurotypical folks method social conditions; if he is left to his personal units, he’ll do issues that make sense to him however do not assist the state of affairs.

In this case, he had two or three issues to take care of.

First, Shaun needed to navigate the twin relationship with Jared and work out find out how to be a superb boss to his buddy. His interpretation of treating Jared the identical means he would every other first-year included anticipating him to hear uncritically to Shaun’s recommendations and comply with protocol to the letter.

The drawback right here was contextual: first-years and attendings work together based mostly on the idea that the brand new residents have no area expertise but and are right here to study sensible expertise for the primary time.

But, as Jared identified, Jared has been out within the area. He’s re-doing the first-year program as a result of that was the one alternative obtainable, not as a result of he would not have the abilities to work at a better stage.

Shaun wanted to take that into consideration and did not accomplish that.

In addition, Shaun’s viewpoint is that medical selections ought to be made objectively, and he did not perceive that the affected person’s psychological and bodily well being affect each other.

That was the actual supply of his and Jared’s battle. Shaun needed to do what was much less dangerous to have the perfect probabilities of prolonging the woman’s life and didn’t perceive why her emotional state was related.

So when Jared tried to clarify how depressed and offended the woman was about her lack of ability to manage her physique, he would possibly as properly have been speaking in a overseas language. Shaun did not perceive what he was saying, and Jared’s makes an attempt to clarify solely obtained him extra upset.

Shaun additionally has points tolerating disagreement due to his challenges in seeing others’ views. In his thoughts, he is proper about EVERYTHING, and he would not perceive how others can see it otherwise.

The case superbly illustrated how neurodiverse kids typically wrestle to be accepted in class. Whether a child has Tourettes, Autism, ADHD, or different neurological variations, different youngsters might bully them for being totally different.

And since many faculties blame victims for bullying regardless of better consciousness than ever that bullying kills, these youngsters are left to determine find out how to deal with it on their very own.

In this case, the affected person internalized loads of the opposite youngsters’ hatred. She needed to be “normal,” no matter that meant.

It wasn’t simply the bullying. That was dangerous sufficient, however she additionally hated that her physique stored doing no matter it felt like, and her mom would not let her make any selections for herself.

No marvel she needed surgical procedure that would doubtlessly eradicate the signs that made her totally different!

I want somebody might have appealed to Shaun’s emotions about rising up totally different. That may need helped him perceive why Jared needed to present this affected person the extra radical surgical procedure.

Jared: I by no means met anybody who needs to go to highschool as a lot as you.
Girl: I hate faculty. But I hate not having any management over my life even worse.

Jared’s answer was excellent, although. Once the affected person’s mom understood what her daughter was going by way of, she modified her thoughts about permitting her to have surgical procedure.

The neatest thing Jared might have finished was encourage mom and daughter to speak actually and hear carefully to one another.

Park’s case had some overlaps. In this non-traditional household, Grandma was in cost, and she or he wasn’t listening to her daughter’s needs or the medical doctors.

She mentioned she needed to do what was greatest for Carter, however she was appearing out of concern greater than anything. Carter was not her son, and his mom needed him to have surgical procedure; thank goodness the grandmother got here round earlier than it was too late.

Park retains getting these cute preschoolers with critical cardiovascular points. One of lately, certainly one of his sufferers will break our hearts!

His case was interspersed with Asher and Jerome’s relationship drama.

I do not know the way I really feel about that battle, which got here out of nowhere.

Jerome’s choice to maintain quiet about his HIV standing affected Asher. Asher may need made totally different selections about defending himself throughout intercourse if he knew Jerome was HIV optimistic.

On the opposite hand, Jerome’s illness is managed so properly that it is undetectable and cannot be handed on to sexual companions, so Asher did not have to make any totally different selections to guard himself.

If the entire battle had been on-screen somewhat than Asher tiptoeing round the truth that he and Jerome had hit a tough patch solely to confront him about this in entrance of Park and Lim, I would really feel otherwise.

But this felt contrived, and Asher wasn’t being honest, which was annoying.

Your flip, The Good Doctor fanatics! Hit the large, blue SHOW COMMENTS button and tell us your ideas.

The Good Doctor would not return till April 3, however you possibly can watch The Good Doctor on-line anytime you need.

The Good Doctor airs on ABC on Mondays at 10 PM EST / PST. The subsequent new episode airs on April 3, 2023.

Edit Delete