There’s a tremendous line between asking for lodging and demanding the world change to swimsuit you, and Charlie crossed it.
On The Good Doctor Season 7 Episode 3, she aggravated Shaun with incessant questions, made inappropriate feedback, and customarily had the perspective that her ASD meant she could not assist any of her habits.
Shaun regarded just like the unhealthy man when he handled her the best way Dr. Han handled him, but he had extra of a degree than anybody acknowledged.
The irony of Shaun making an attempt to pressure Charlie into pathology after Han doing the identical factor to him was not misplaced on Glassman or Lim.
While Shaun’s frustration with Charlie was comprehensible, it wasn’t plausible that it by no means crossed his thoughts that Charlie would really feel the identical approach about it that he did when he was receiving it. Glassman’s reminder that Han did the identical factor ought to have made him assume twice.
Was Dr. Han Like Shaun Is Being With Charlie?
Dr. Han was Chief of Surgery throughout The Good Doctor Season 2. He disliked Shaun’s bluntness and was uncomfortable with him as a result of he was autistic.
Han believed Shaun’s issues made him unable to be a surgeon, assigned him to the pathology lab as a substitute, and fired him when Shaun had a meltdown about it.
At the time, Han was the most recent physician to determine that Shaun could not be a surgeon as a result of he was autistic, and it was annoying and out of contact with actuality.
Given his expertise with Han’s nonsense, Shaun’s insistence that Charlie would by no means be a surgeon was a step too far. Shaun tends to assume he is proper even when others in comparable conditions are flawed. Still, he is often capable of see one other perspective when reminded of how he felt in an identical scenario.
Was Charlie LIke Shaun Used to Be?
There was a crucial distinction between Shaun and Charlie.
Shaun Murphy has by no means thought of his ASD a incapacity. He has accomplished his finest to succeed regardless of his challenges, whereas Charlie interprets ‘lodging’ to imply that she by no means has to vary her habits as a result of she’s neurodivergent.
Charlie’s perspective aggravated me. I’m way more like Shaun in that I’ve all the time seen my autism-related challenges as ability deficits that may be overcome slightly than being set in stone.
Autistic individuals who cross the road from needing lodging to utilizing their prognosis to excuse unhealthy habits are one among my pet peeves. And that is precisely what Charlie was doing.
I get a few of what she was saying. I’m delicate to raised voices, too, and am extra more likely to grow to be startled and defensive than be taught something if somebody raises their voice even barely.
But that does not imply that something goes. Charlie went past speaking that problem to demanding that others settle for any approach she selected to talk. Having a incapacity doesn’t suggest that one is resistant to penalties for his or her phrases and actions.
Kalu: Charlie?
Charlie: Hmm?
Kalu: It may be higher to be your genuine self with out interrupting your boss.
Charlie’s response to Jared suggesting she should not have interaction in inappropriate office conversations irritated me much more than her interactions with Shaun. Being autistic doesn’t suggest she has a inexperienced gentle to make others uncomfortable, and it isn’t a violation of the ADA to insist she chorus from particular matters of dialog.
Charlie’s Attitude is a Poor Representation of Autism
While it is nice that an autistic actress performs Charlie, this isn’t good autistic illustration. Autistic persons are not all unable to take suggestions into consideration, nor can we all must battle to be seen as helpful staff.
We’ve had two autistic characters, and each of them have had a tough time succeeding as a surgeon due to their autism. That’s a drained TV trope about autism that should go.
The Good Doctor has accomplished rather a lot to normalize autism. Still, when it depicts autistic folks as all the time making others uncomfortable and unable to deal with the social facet of the office, it does not do us any favors.
Charlie’s lack of ability to simply accept criticism is near being a poisonous trait. I did not blame Shaun for not desirous to work along with her, even when this office cut up for the sake of drama is written as if he is insensitive to her emotions and refusing to see that she’s rather a lot like he was when he first began.
Glassman And Lim’s Conflict is Overplayed
Glassman and Lim continued preventing over facets of their co-presidency. This sniping wasn’t entertaining when Morgan and Park did it, and it wasn’t any higher right here.
This time round, Aaron Glassman’s perspective that if he ignored their calls for, they’d go away made no sense. Dealing with the hospital board requires political savvy, however ignoring board members’ communications wasn’t the easiest way to do that.
Did Glassman succeed earlier than by doing that? Really?
Or was he saying issues to get Lim’s goat?
That fecal pattern fridge Lim needed him to arrange higher characteristic prominently in a future episode after all of the speaking she did about it!
Asher’s Struggles Were Relatable
Asher’s refusal to go to Jeremy’s niece’s affirmation did not take up an excessive amount of of the hour, however his problem with this was relatable.
Ash, I’ve tried to be delicate to your loved ones historical past, however mine’s not the identical. We’re all tremendous shut.
Jeremy
Asher Wolke’s all the time been considerably of a lone wolf due to his battle together with his non secular group, particularly his mother and father. Understandably, he would not prioritize a household celebration or really feel snug with Jerome’s household, particularly if he does not know them effectively.
When he lastly overcame his reluctance, he bonded with Jerome’s niece. As an introvert with social nervousness, I appreciated this story and its final result.
Was All That Blood and Gore Necessary?
I’m with Dom — the quantity of blood on medical dramas makes me queasy, too.
This was a very gross, Monkey’s Paw-like case, with a butcher dropping his hand in a meat grinder accident. Still, Dom’s lack of ability to face the sight of blood is getting previous.
I’m positive some medical doctors really feel that approach, however he has to get by means of his surgical rotation by some means, and he wants a narrative past fainting each time he is within the OR!
I preferred how he stood as much as Morgan (who’s again to ridiculous storylines after being extra sympathetic and mature than she was.). And I recognize Park being extra affected person with him than Shaun’s been with Charlie.
This case might have been grotesque, but it surely was extra compelling than the man who swallowed a part of a barbecue brush. I’m fairly positive that occurred to somebody on Chicago Med not too long ago, and I used to be distracted making an attempt to recollect.
Your flip, The Good Doctor fanatics.
Hit the massive, blue SHOW COMMENTS button and tell us your ideas in regards to the episode.
The Good Doctor airs on ABC on Tuesdays at 10/9c.
Jack Ori is a senior employees author for TV Fanatic. His debut younger grownup novel, Reinventing Hannah, is obtainable on Amazon. Follow him on X.
Discussion about this post