Scout Comics, a small, unbiased comics writer that hadn’t been pinging on many business observer radars has been instantly thrust into the a highlight – however not in the best way they could have hoped for. A squadron of disgruntled creators have been talking out on social media about their remedy by Scout Comics, alleging non-payment, ghosting and threats of blackballing. Even a short investigation into the allegations has uncovered much more complaints about unapproved merchandise and covers, and, as one creator advised me, “over-promising and under-delivering.”
Before we dig in, I ought to be aware that Chris Arrant at Popverse has a wonderful overview of the story up to now, and Sky Hawkins at League of Comics Geeks (a comics assortment monitoring web site) has been collating allegations, together with some new ones which can be fairly shocking. You can learn that in [PART 1] [PART 2] [PART 3].
Things kicked off final week when Jarred Luján, just lately introduced as the brand new co-writer of Mezo, let unfastened in a tweet thread:
If you’re a brand new creator, please keep away from @ScoutComics just like the plague. Haven’t paid me for a ebook out over a 12 months. Won’t reply emails. We delivered a accomplished, worthwhile ebook and nonetheless received screwed.
Spoke to the Editorial Director and he implied we’d be blacklisted for complaining. CEO got here in appearing like he’d assist and now he’s ghosting us too. If it’s like that at the highest, why all the pieces else sucks.
I’ve tried for a 12 months to work with these folks and its clear they don’t have any intention of working with us. Nothing resembling a partnership.
I additionally received a single assertion about ebook gross sales and never a single one since.
Can’t promote books, can’t pay creators, however they received a full @Whatnot schedule!
My final e mail a month in the past was “hey can you just cancel our contract and we can move past the money you owe me” and so they nonetheless didn’t reply. That would have price zero {dollars}, for no matter thats price.
These allegations broke the dam on different creators with related tales, together with Honor Vincent, Rebecca Good, Brian Wickman, Adam Barnhardt, Massimo Rosi, Matthew Erman, Dakota Brown, and…..properly, you get the thought. Lots and many creators. (Evan Okay. Prozias stepped up with reward for Scout, it ought to be famous.)
Perhaps essentially the most severe allegation got here in a now deleted tweet from a Scout creator who wrote: “Where was this accountability when we repeatedly asked for details and figures and were instead greeted with anger. Denied a contract termination unless we paid 75k for the huge overprint we didn’t ask for. This is a company full of grifters, don’t believe a word of this at all.”
That was in reference to Scout’s official response to Luján’s claims, a press release made on their social media with feedback off. It reads:
Dear comics group,
Scout began as and stays an organization created by and for creators. We love comics. We love studying comics, making comics, and publishing comics for different creators. We love the comics group.
While Scout has all the time striven to keep up excessive ranges of service to our groups, just lately a inventive crew expressed their frustration publicly as a consequence of not having had a response to their issues in a number of months. This is true. We dropped the ball by failing to reply in a well timed method. We take full duty for our lack of response at that point as a consequence of inner miscommunication.
Regardless, we’ll proceed to try to do higher and enhance communication with all of our creators. Despite the complaints we’ve got seen on-line, Scout has had only a few creators attain out to us immediately with issues. We have really had a number of creators attain out and help, which we recognize.
As with all companies, there will probably be missteps. The most necessary factor is to be taught. At this time, we’re overtly welcoming any creator with a title at scout comics to achieve out to our COO Lesa Miller at [email redacted] with any issues they might have. All issues will probably be listened to and all inquiries will probably be responded to in a well timed method.
As creators ourselves we perceive the problems which were introduced to us. Thank you on your persistence and style whereas we endeavor to be taught from the suggestions we’re receiving.
This response didn’t go over properly, because it typically admitted that the “ghosting” many creators had complained of had taken place, and left many severe allegations unresolved.
Now how did we get right here? Scout Comics, (or to offer it its full title, Scout Comics and Entertainment Holdings, Inc) has been round for some time, beginning out as Ardden Entertainment, and rebranding as Scout Comics in 2015. The essential participant behind each is Brenden Deneen, Scout’s present CEO, who has a prolonged CV as an agent and growth government, together with eight years as an government editor working MacMillan’s leisure wing, together with stints at The Weinstein Company and Fineprint Literary Management. He’s additionally at present the Head of Film/TV at Blackstone Pub, in accordance with his twitter bio. As if that didn’t preserve him busy sufficient, he’s additionally an creator, with books about Guardians of the Galaxy, Morbius and Alien to his title. Among his books: a 4 quantity sequence referred to as Night Night Groot.
Scout’s different essential government is president James Haick III. At one level, Joe Pruett was co-publisher, though he left and was changed by Charlie Stickney, who left the corporate in 2022 solely to get replaced by Pruett once more.
Perhaps a number of the present troubles will be traced to one thing Stickney wrote in his farewell letter:
Over the final couple of years Scout has grown from a small firm placing out 6-10 titles a month to at least one that’s internationally identified with a slate of choices that may method 25 books month-to-month. With a number of imprints, a toy line, a gaming division and a number of titles in growth as movies and tv sequence—in all that development I consider the time has come for me to move the baton to the subsequent particular person into what I’m positive will probably be a really profitable future for Scout.
That seems like a variety of growth for an organization that doesn’t actually have many well-known hit books to its credit score. (Their finest promoting title, I’m advised, has been Stabbity Bunny.) I recall seeing the Scout sales space at the 2021 Thanksgiving San Diego Comic-Con: it was a newly expanded affair, and I chatted with a number of the people at the sales space who stated they have been seeking to develop and make a transfer. As everyone knows, Pandemic period development was an outlier and issues are settling again to regular…or worse.
I reached out to a couple of the disgruntled Scout creators and received related tales from them. One of them supplied me with a pattern contract from Scout, which confirms that that they had a “shared revenue” mannequin. While the creators retain all rights and copyrights, Scout indicators them up for a 5 12 months publishing deal, with a 50/50 cut up on royalties, which come solely after printing bills have been taken out. A separate settlement covers media rights, with Deneen representing properties for growth, and both 5 or ten 12 months phrases, with Scout locked in as a producer ought to something attain the display screen. I haven’t learn as many media contracts as I’ve publishing ones, however this one appears fairly commonplace (if hardly great) in a time when stockpiling IP is the primary perform of comics publishers. Overall, the publishing finish is an “Image lite” deal that appeared to attraction primarily to up and coming creators. Established creators can go for the actual Image deal.
I’ll say, having seen many shitty, shitty comics publishing offers over time, having the creator keep possession is at least a greater begin, and explains why so many creators have been capable of get their publishing rights again pretty cleanly, in accordance with Twitter.
That’s the great half. The dangerous half is that of late Scout appears to have a variety of issues maintaining with royalty statements, amongst different issues, and plenty of books by no means got here into the black when a press release did arrive. Allegedly commerce collections have been by no means printed, books have been delayed for no purpose, schedules have been erratic, and books simply by no means got here out. A reboot of the 80s hit Maze Agency has been introduced TWICE, as soon as in 2022, and once more in 2023.
There have been many sources for the disappointment. One creator advised me that that they had seen covers and what seems like “digital collectibles” that they had by no means accepted. In addition, Scout has been more and more lively on the “Twitch meets eBay” web site Whatnot, one thing many creators talked about of their social media posts, an exercise that enormously added to anger over the ghosting.
Taking a glance at the general image, it’s onerous to not see an organization that offered a variety of comics, like everybody, in the course of the keep at dwelling Pandemic years, then expanded too quick, and received out over their skis for the current “crashing periodical comics sales” period.
But that’s simply the latest growth. Looked at a method, Scout concentrated on working with starting creators, and supplied a spot to get printed for newcomers. They appear to have been capable of carry this out since 2015, though I can’t consider many comics family names who received their begin there. Some folks have been positively okay with the deal they received.
Looked at one other manner, nonetheless, this was a shell sport for media rights – call it the “Men in Black” enterprise mannequin, hoping a unicorn wanders in from left subject and turns into a cultural mainstay. And as the various disillusioned and indignant creators present, the advertising and help weren’t all the time there, particularly just lately. And Scout appears to have had no actual editorial division or infrastructure to help creators. (According to a BlueSky posting, some Scout creators are literally contemplating a category motion go well with.)
It was a variety of little issues that added up. As Honor Vincent wrote of her ebook New Rat City:
I discovered concerning the FOC for Issue #1 after I went to a comic book store to ask in the event that they carried Scout; it was that day (mortifying!!). Marketing plans have been promised, then by no means occurred.
The ebook wasn’t added to their web site till two days after its launch date, and after I needed to e mail to ask why. The TPB that was purported to occur – which they’ve had within the can for a 12 months and a half – doesn’t appear to be.
Another creator advised me in an e mail that they had been making an attempt to get out of their contract since 2022 as a consequence of unhappiness over how their ebook was being dealt with. Attempts to get publishing rights again have been allegedly “met with hostility, threat of blacklisting, and ceased communication from everyone but their lawyer.”
Luján, the unique whistleblower, was capable of get his rights again and wrote:
Two issues: 1. I’ve no intention to do press as of proper now. There are a number of creators who’ve come ahead. Amplify them. 2. I’m sorry this has occurred to so many. I consider in every one in every of you and the tales you need to inform. Don’t hand over on yourselves.
Scout is drafting a termination settlement for us and claims to mean to pay us, although I’ll maintain my breath till the cash deposits and the paperwork is signed.
Louis Southard, one other Scout creator, posted a “hypothetical essay” on Twitter. The sort is small however the message is massive.
I did attain out to Scout Comics for a press release, and president Haick answered a few of my questions.
I requested concerning the doubling of the publishing line, and whether or not it was an excessive amount of too quick. “It is our mission to bring independent voices to the market,” he advised me. “It is clear that the comic book sales marketplace has changed dramatically from the early pandemic – when the demand for entertainment soared – to post-pandemic when supply chain issues brought it crashing down with paper shortages nearly doubling the cost to print. Scout is not alone among publishers in seeing a diminished customer base, which we are proud to have offset with innovative alternate sales channels, such as our selling Pressworks – actual printer plates from a comic book’s print run, to WhatNot sales, to our new build-a-box subscription box.”
As for the present market, “Again, with diminishing distribution numbers across small-to-mid sized publishers, we have utilized creativity and an ability to pivot to get Scout books into the hands of fans. This remains our goal,” stated Haick.
I introduced up the allegations concerning a $75,000 invoice for an overprint. While he didn’t tackle all of the claims, Haick says they didn’t take into account the overprinting large. “We believed it to be a smart investment in the title. It was set to be a series of one-shots (i.e. an evergreen product) and based on overall preorder numbers, we were able to print more for significantly less investment thanks to the economies of scale. When printing comics using offset printing, the cost-per-unit lessens significantly when the quantity increases. We, and most other publishers, do this so we can sell the additional quantities via higher profit margin revenue channels like our website and conventions. Everyone at Scout believed in their book, which is why the additional investment was made.”
Ultimately, Scout Comics’ area of interest has been as a small writer for starting creators who are studying the ropes – together with that small publishers are sometimes dangerous at communication, sending out royalty statements, and protecting creators within the loop. It’s an unlucky and infrequently pointless training. Sadly, getting handled poorly by a small writer (and infrequently a big one) is nearly a typical within the comics business. As one creator advised me, “It’s almost as if every comics creator has to go through their rite of passage being published by a semi-shitty company that over-promises and under-delivers.”
I might write a for much longer essay about why that shouldn’t be. Publishers have to do higher. And we’d like higher sources to coach starting creators on what to ask for and how you can spot the pink flags. But that’s for one more day.
It’s plain that Scout’s popularity has taken fairly successful in all this and I requested Haick how they may regain the belief of the group. “I have personally reached out to over a hundred Scout creators since last week, including the ones who are speaking out online,” he advised me. “We are determining amicable options with them. It’s necessary to notice that we’ve got heard from simply as many creators who’re expressing appreciation for us and their want to proceed working with Scout.
“We are a small company with a small staff, but we are committed to improving our communication going forward. And we continue to encourage any and all Scout creators to email us about any questions or concerns they have.”
Will that be sufficient? If Scout is honest about doing higher with communications they might earn again a few of that belief, but it surely’s going to take some time – and within the midst of big business headwinds.
I do have a constructive out of all of this. The younger creators I’ve spoken with about their Scout experiences have been a refreshing bunch. They are sensible and gifted and so they need to be handled with skilled respect. I’m positive they’ll go on to higher issues…and a few already are.
Discussion about this post